Question 1
1 markA student used a digital thermometer to measure the temperature of a water bath five times. Without the student knowing, the thermometer always reads 2.0 °C higher than the true temperature.
Compared with readings from an accurate thermometer, what is the effect on the mean and on the spread of the five readings?
Choose your answer.
- A The mean is the same and the spread is larger.
- B The mean is the same and the spread is the same.
- C The mean is too high and the spread is larger.
- D The mean is too high and the spread is the same.
Model answer
D (The mean is too high and the spread is the same.)
Explanation
A systematic error makes every reading wrong by the same amount in the same direction, so it affects accuracy (the mean is wrong) but not precision (the spread). Repeating the readings and taking a mean cannot remove a systematic error; the thermometer must be checked against a reliable one. Random errors are different: they make readings scatter around the true value.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / The mean is too high and the spread is the same.
The only correct answer is D: this is a systematic error, which shifts every reading by the same amount (2.0 °C), so the mean is 2.0 °C too high but the readings are just as close together as before. A and B are not correct because every reading, and so the mean, is too high; C is not correct because a constant error does not make the readings more spread out (random errors do that). ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.