Read the following conversation between two friends.
Sam: 'I got a C in my mock exam. It just proves I'm stupid - I'll fail everything.'
Leah: 'But you got an A in your last test!'
Sam: 'That was just luck. The test must have been really easy.'
Sam has been feeling low for several weeks.
How can the psychological explanation of depression be used to explain Sam's way of thinking? Refer to the conversation in your answer.
Model answer
The psychological explanation suggests that depression is influenced by nurture: through experiences such as criticism or failure, people can develop negative schemas, which are pessimistic sets of beliefs about themselves, the world and the future. They may also have a negative attributional style, where bad events are explained by internal, stable and global causes and good events by external, unstable and specific ones.
Sam's thinking fits this closely. He sees his C as proof that he is 'stupid', which is an internal attribution for a bad event. 'I'll fail everything' is stable and global, because he assumes one disappointing grade applies to all his future exams. In contrast, he explains his A as 'luck' and the test being 'easy', which are external and unstable attributions, so he gains no confidence from success. Ignoring the evidence of the A grade suggests he has a negative schema about himself that biases how he processes information, which would keep his mood low.
The explanation therefore accounts for Sam's thinking well, and it suggests a way to help him: CBT could help him to challenge these thoughts, for example by looking at the evidence of his A grade. However, the conversation cannot show that his thinking caused his low mood, because negative thinking can also be a result of feeling low. Biological factors, such as an imbalance of serotonin, could also be involved, so the psychological explanation may be only part of the picture.
Explanation
Level 3 needs all three skills: accurate description of schemas and attributions, precise links to Sam's words (internal, stable, global for the C; external, unstable for the A), and analysis of how well the explanation fits, including the cause-or-effect problem. A common pitfall is to give a personal opinion about Sam rather than using the psychological explanation.