Practise 30 exam-style questions on Obedience for AQA GCSE Psychology (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.
30 questions
1–9 marks each
Instant marking
No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go
Sample questions with model answers
Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.
Question 1
1 mark
Which one of the following statements about Adorno's F-scale is correct?
Choose your answer.
It was a questionnaire used to measure authoritarian personality traits
It measured the highest voltage a person was willing to give
It was an observation of how often people conform in groups
It recorded how close a person stood to an authority figure
Model answer
It was a questionnaire used to measure authoritarian personality traits
Explanation
Adorno's F-scale was a questionnaire on which people rated how far they agreed with statements; a high score suggested an Authoritarian Personality. The voltage scale belongs to Milgram's shock generator, which is a common mix-up, and the F-scale did not measure conformity or proximity.
Mark scheme
1 mark
It was a questionnaire used to measure authoritarian personality traits
If more than one option is given, 0 marks.
Question 2
2 marks
Proximity is a social factor that affects obedience.
Explain how obedience is affected by proximity to the authority figure and by proximity to the person affected by the order.
Model answer
The closer the authority figure is, the more likely people are to obey; when orders are given from a distance, such as by telephone, obedience falls. However, the closer people are to the person affected by the order, the less likely they are to obey, because they can see the consequences of their actions and feel more responsible for them.
Explanation
The two kinds of proximity work in opposite directions: being close to the authority figure increases obedience, but being close to the person who will be harmed reduces it. Each mark needs the direction of the effect, and Milgram's variations (telephone orders, the learner in the same room) are good evidence to include.
Mark scheme
1 mark
1 mark for explaining that the closer the authority figure is, the more likely people are to obey / people are less likely to obey an authority figure who gives orders from a distance
Accept Milgram's finding that obedience fell sharply when the experimenter gave orders by telephone from another room (accept figures of about 20-23%). The direction of the effect must be clear.
1 mark
1 mark for explaining that the closer the person affected by the order is, the less likely people are to obey / people find it harder to harm someone who is right next to them
Accept an explanation in terms of seeing the consequences, feeling more responsible or moral strain. Accept Milgram's findings: 40% obeyed fully when the learner was in the same room and 30% when the participant had to press the learner's hand onto a plate, compared with 65% when the learner was in another room. Do not accept 'proximity affects obedience' with no direction.
Question 3
3 marks
A psychologist, Dr Petrakis (fictional), gave the F-scale to 75 office workers. 26 of them scored as highly authoritarian.
Calculate the percentage of office workers who scored as highly authoritarian. Give your answer to two significant figures and show your workings.
Model answer
26 ÷ 75 = 0.34666... 0.34666... × 100 = 34.666...% To two significant figures = 35%
Explanation
Divide 26 by 75 and multiply by 100 to get 34.666...%. To two significant figures this rounds up to 35%, because the third figure (6) is 5 or more. Rounding down to 34 or stopping at 34.7 are the usual ways to lose a mark.
Mark scheme
3 marks
3 marks for the correct percentage to two significant figures: 35(%). 2 marks for the correct percentage but not rounded to two significant figures: 34.7 / 34.67 / 34.667. 1 mark for correct workings but incorrect/no answer: 26 ÷ 75 × 100.
A correct answer scores 3 marks even without workings. Accept 35 with or without the % sign. Also award 2 marks for 34 (the correct percentage rounded incorrectly), as AQA did for a similar error in its June 2024 Paper 2 mark scheme. Accept answers written in the workings. 65% (the percentage who did not score as highly authoritarian) scores 0.
Question 4
6 marks
Describe how authority and proximity affect obedience, according to Milgram, and evaluate the evidence from his research.
Model answer
According to Milgram, people are more likely to obey someone they see as a legitimate authority, meaning someone who has, or seems to have, the right to give orders. In his original study, 65% of participants went to 450 volts when ordered by an experimenter in a grey coat at Yale University. When the study moved to a run-down office building, obedience fell to 47.5%, and when an ordinary man gave the orders it fell to 20%. Proximity also matters. Being close to the authority figure increases obedience, so when the experimenter gave orders by telephone, obedience fell sharply. Being close to the person affected reduces obedience: it fell to 40% when the learner was in the same room and to 30% when participants had to press his hand onto a shock plate.
This evidence is strong in some ways. Milgram changed one factor at a time while keeping the rest of the procedure the same, so he could show that authority and proximity caused the changes in obedience. However, the laboratory setting and the task of giving shocks were artificial, so people may behave differently in everyday situations. The original sample was only 40 American men, which limits generalisation. The research also raised serious ethical issues, as participants were deceived and very stressed. Overall, Milgram's variations give clear evidence that authority and proximity affect obedience, although the exact figures may not apply in real life.
Explanation
Level 3 answers explain both factors and support them with accurate figures from Milgram's variations, then evaluate how good that evidence is and reach a conclusion. Remember that proximity works in two directions: being close to the authority figure raises obedience, while being close to the learner lowers it. Simply listing percentages without explaining what they show about each factor limits the AO1 marks.
Mark scheme
6 marks
Levels of response (6 marks). AO1 - 3 marks and AO3 - 3 marks. Level 3 Detailed (5-6 marks): AO1: Relevant knowledge and understanding of how authority and proximity affect obedience is accurate with detail. AO3: Analysis and evaluation of the evidence from Milgram's research is effective. Any conclusions drawn are sound and fully expressed. Relevant terminology is used consistently throughout. The answer demonstrates a high level of substantiated reasoning, is clear, coherent and focused. Level 2 Clear (3-4 marks): AO1: Relevant knowledge and understanding of how authority and proximity affect obedience is present but there are occasional inaccuracies/omissions. AO3: There may be some effective analysis and evaluation of the evidence from Milgram's research. There may be an attempt to draw conclusions. Relevant terminology is occasionally used. The answer occasionally demonstrates substantiated reasoning, but may lack clarity, coherence, focus and logical structure. Level 1 Basic (1-2 marks): AO1: Knowledge and understanding of how authority and proximity affect obedience is present but limited. AO3: Analysis and evaluation of the evidence from Milgram's research is of limited effectiveness or may be absent. Any attempts to draw conclusions are not always successful or present. Relevant terminology may not be used at all or may be muddled. 0 marks: No relevant content.
Possible content (not a checklist): AO1 - Authority: people are more likely to obey someone they see as a legitimate authority, i.e. someone who has (or seems to have) the right to give orders, shown by symbols such as uniforms and by a respected setting. In Milgram's original study, 65% went to 450 volts when ordered by an experimenter in a grey coat at Yale University; obedience fell to 47.5% in a run-down office building and to 20% when an ordinary man gave the orders. Proximity: being close to the authority figure increases obedience - when the experimenter gave orders by telephone, obedience fell sharply; being close to the person affected reduces obedience - 40% when the learner was in the same room and 30% when participants had to press the learner's hand onto a plate. AO3 - Milgram's variations changed one factor at a time in a controlled laboratory setting, so they give strong evidence that authority and proximity cause changes in obedience. The procedure was standardised (e.g. the same prods), so it could be repeated. However, the setting and task were artificial, so the findings may not apply to everyday obedience; some participants may have suspected the shocks were not real. The original sample was 40 American men, so generalisation is limited. Real-world evidence, such as Hofling's study, in which 21 of 22 nurses were prepared to give an overdose when told to by a doctor on the phone, supports the role of authority. The research raised serious ethical issues (deception, stress, difficulty withdrawing). Credit other relevant content. NOTE: Accept close values for the telephone variation (about 20-23%) and for the other variations. NOTE: The AO3 may be embedded in the AO1 or separate; both are equally acceptable.
Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.
Ctrl + Enter to check
Study HelperHints first, answers after you try
Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.