A team of neuroscientists wants to find out which areas of the brain are active when people recognise the faces of their family members. They plan to scan 30 adult volunteers with fMRI while photographs of familiar and unfamiliar faces appear on a screen.
Explain the strengths and weaknesses of using fMRI scans to study brain functioning. In your answer, refer to the neuroscientists' study.
Model answer
fMRI has several strengths for this study. It shows brain activity while a task is being done, so the neuroscientists can compare the brain's response to familiar and unfamiliar faces and see which areas become more active when a family member's face appears. It involves no radiation and no injection, so it is non-invasive; this makes it ethically acceptable to scan 30 healthy volunteers, and each can be shown many photographs over several trials. fMRI also gives detailed images that pinpoint active areas more precisely than a PET scan, and it produces objective data that the volunteers cannot easily fake.
However, there are weaknesses. fMRI measures changes in blood flow, which lag a few seconds behind the activity of neurons, yet people recognise a familiar face in a fraction of a second, so the timing of the processes involved is hard to pin down. The volunteers must lie still in a noisy, enclosed scanner looking at photographs on a screen, which is very different from recognising a relative in everyday life, so the findings may lack ecological validity; some volunteers may also find the scanner stressful, or be excluded because of metal implants. fMRI is very expensive, which may limit the size of the sample. Finally, the scans show that an area is active when faces are recognised, not that it causes recognition.
Overall, fMRI is a suitable method for this study, as long as the team bears these limitations in mind when interpreting the results.
Explanation
Top answers explain at least two strengths and two weaknesses of fMRI and tie each to this study, for example comparing activity for familiar and unfamiliar faces (strength) and the delay in blood flow compared with how quickly faces are recognised (weakness). A list of features of fMRI without explaining why they matter for this study stays in the lower levels.