Read the following article.
Is modern life making us unwell?
A report on one English town has found that the number of adults being treated for mental health problems has risen sharply over the past ten years. Over the same period, more people in the town have started living alone, many now commute long distances to work, and a large local employer has closed. The report also notes that GPs in the town have held mental health awareness events, and more people say they now feel able to talk about their mental health.
How can the increased challenges of modern living be used to explain the rise in the number of adults being treated for mental health problems in the town? Refer to the article in your answer.
Model answer
The increased challenges of modern living are features of life today that can make it harder to stay mentally healthy, such as isolation, work and financial pressures, and the pressures of social media. They can increase stress while reducing the social support that helps people to cope effectively with challenges.
The article describes several of these challenges. More people in the town now live alone, so more may be isolated, with nobody to talk to when problems arise. Many commute long distances, leaving less time for friends, family and activities that protect wellbeing. The closure of a large employer is likely to have caused unemployment and money worries, and losing a job also removes daily routine and contact with colleagues. Together these changes could mean that more people in the town are actually developing mental health problems.
However, the rise may not be entirely due to modern living. The article says GPs have held awareness events and more people feel able to talk about their mental health. This suggests that increased recognition and less stigma mean that more people are now seeking treatment for problems that were previously hidden, so some of the rise may be in recorded cases rather than in real cases. Also, the report only shows that these changes happened at the same time, which does not prove that modern living caused the rise. Overall, the challenges of modern living probably explain part of the rise, alongside more people seeking help.
Explanation
Top answers explain how each challenge in the article (living alone, long commutes, job losses) could affect mental health, then weigh this against the article's evidence that more people are seeking help because of awareness and less stigma. Concluding that part of the rise may be in recorded cases, and that changes happening together do not prove cause, gives the analysis needed for Level 3.