Read the account.
Matteo grew up in southern Italy and has just started at a sixth-form college in Manchester. He says: 'At home, friends stand close and touch your arm when they chat. Here, when I stand close to people, they step backwards. One girl told me I was invading her space. I wasn't trying to be rude.'
How can cultural differences in personal space be used to explain Matteo's experience? Refer to the account in your answer.
Model answer
Personal space is the area around a person that they treat as their own, and the amount of space people prefer is partly learned from their culture. In contact cultures, such as Mediterranean and Latin American cultures, people tend to stand close together and touch each other during casual conversations. In non-contact cultures, such as North American, northern European and many Asian cultures, people prefer a larger personal space and touch less.
Matteo grew up in southern Italy, a Mediterranean contact culture, so for him standing close to friends and touching their arm is normal. In Manchester, people tend to follow non-contact norms and prefer more space, so when Matteo stands at the distance he is used to, they step backwards to restore their personal space. The girl feels that he is invading her space because he is closer than her cultural norm, even though Matteo is simply following his own norm and does not mean to be rude.
This explanation works well, because the problem only began when Matteo moved between cultures, and both he and the other students are behaving normally for their own culture. However, other factors may also play a part. The students are new to him, and people keep more distance from people they do not know well, and the girl may prefer more space with a male. Not everyone in a culture behaves the same way, so cultural differences describe general tendencies and should not be used to stereotype individuals. Overall, culture is the most likely explanation, but probably not the only one.
Explanation
Level 3 answers describe contact and non-contact cultures, apply them to both Matteo and the people in Manchester, and then judge how far culture explains the situation compared with other factors such as familiarity and gender. Retelling the account without the psychology, or giving no judgement at all, keeps an answer in the lower levels.