Daniel has depression. His doctor has prescribed an SSRI and explained that it should increase the amount of serotonin available in his brain. Daniel has not been offered any other treatment.
Explain the strengths and weaknesses of a reductionist approach to treating depression. Refer to Daniel's treatment in your answer.
Model answer
A reductionist approach explains and treats behaviour by breaking it down into its simplest parts. Daniel's treatment is reductionist because it treats his depression as a problem of one biological factor, too little serotonin, and ignores his thoughts, experiences and relationships.
One strength of this approach is that it has a clear, specific target that can be tested scientifically; for example, an SSRI can be compared with a placebo in a controlled trial, so there is evidence about whether it works. The treatment is also simple and quick to give: Daniel's doctor can prescribe tablets straight away without Daniel needing to attend weekly sessions, and antidepressants reduce symptoms for many people.
However, a reductionist approach deals with symptoms rather than causes. If Daniel's depression is linked to negative thinking or stressful events in his life, the SSRI will not change these, so his symptoms may return when he stops taking it. Not everyone responds to antidepressants, and they take several weeks to work and can cause side effects, so relying on one treatment leaves Daniel with no alternative if it does not help. Wiles' study found that adding CBT to antidepressants was more effective than antidepressants alone, which suggests that a more holistic approach, dealing with thoughts as well as brain chemistry, would be more effective.
Overall, the reductionist approach has helped to produce useful treatments, but Daniel may benefit more from a holistic plan that also addresses his thinking and circumstances.
Explanation
Level 3 answers explain what reductionism is, show why Daniel's treatment is reductionist, and weigh developed strengths (a testable, simple, quick treatment) against weaknesses (it treats symptoms not causes, relapse, Wiles' evidence for a combined approach) before reaching a conclusion. Answers that describe SSRIs without discussing reductionism stay in the lower levels.