In 2019 the government of Country X introduced a sugar tax of 25p per litre on soft drinks containing more than 5g of sugar per 100ml. The tax is paid by the producers of the drinks, and the revenue is spent on sport in schools. The aim of the tax is to reduce obesity and the costs it creates for the health service, which are paid for by taxpayers.
Many producers reduced the sugar in their drinks so that the drinks were no longer taxed. However, some doctors point out that children also get sugar from sweets, cakes and other foods, which are not taxed.
Figure 1 shows data for Country X from 2018 to 2024.
Using Figure 1, assess whether the sugar tax has been successful in reducing the negative externalities caused by sugary drinks.
Model answer
The sugar tax has clearly changed what is sold. Figure 1 shows that the average sugar content of soft drinks fell from 6.8g per 100ml in 2018 to 3.9g in 2024, about 43%, and sales of high-sugar drinks fell from 1,450 million to 820 million litres, also about 43%. Because the tax is paid by producers, many reduced the sugar in their drinks to get below the 5g limit and avoid it, so consumers now take in much less sugar from drinks. Less sugar should, over time, mean less obesity, diabetes and tooth decay, which reduces the costs that fall on the health service and on taxpayers: the negative externality. The tax also raises revenue, £205 million in 2024, which is spent on school sport and so helps children's health further.
However, the final aim is to reduce obesity, and Figure 1 shows little sign of that. The share of children aged 10-11 who are obese was 21.0% in 2018 and still 20.9% in 2024, and it even rose to 21.3% in 2022. One reason is that children also get sugar from sweets, cakes and other foods that are not taxed, so they may have replaced some of the sugar from drinks. Obesity also depends on exercise and diet as a whole, and health improvements take many years to appear, so the external costs of obesity may not yet have fallen. The tax is also regressive, taking more of the income of poorer households, and as the tax works the revenue falls (from £280 million in 2020 to £205 million in 2024), leaving less money for school sport.
Overall, I think the sugar tax has been successful at its direct aim of cutting the sugar in soft drinks, but it is too early to say that it has reduced the negative externalities of obesity, because the obesity rate has hardly changed. Whether it succeeds depends on the time allowed and on other policies: on its own it is not enough, and it would work better alongside measures on sugary foods, limits on advertising to children and information campaigns.
Explanation
Strong answers separate the direct effect (much less sugar in drinks and fewer high-sugar drinks sold) from the final aim (lower obesity and lower health service costs), use the figures for both, and reach a judgement that explains what success depends on. Answers that only describe the table, or argue that the tax 'worked' without noticing the obesity column, cannot reach Level 3.