Country X has a top rate of income tax of 40% and low welfare benefits. Its neighbour, Country Y, has a higher top rate of income tax and more generous benefits for low-income families. Figure 1 compares the two countries.
The government of Country X is considering raising its top rate of income tax and using the extra revenue to increase benefits for low-income families. Some economists warn that this would reduce the incentive to work, invest and start businesses, and that some highly paid workers might move abroad. Others argue that high inequality causes social problems and that growth is of little use to people who do not share in it.
Using Figure 1, assess whether the government of Country X should make reducing inequality a higher priority than economic growth.
Model answer
Figure 1 suggests that Country X's faster growth has not benefited everyone. Country X has grown by 2.6% a year since 2015, faster than Country Y's 1.9%, and its GDP per capita is about 9.7% higher (£34 000 against £31 000). Yet the poorest 10% of people in Country X have an average income of only £9800, about 12.5% less than the £11 200 received by the poorest 10% in Country Y. The richest 10% in Country X receive 35% of all income, compared with 24% in Country Y. This shows that a higher average income can hide large differences: many of the gains from growth in Country X have gone to people at the top. High inequality can lead to poverty, poorer health and lower educational achievement for children from low-income families, as well as crime and social tension. Raising the top rate of tax to pay for higher benefits would raise the incomes of the poorest families, and because they spend most of any extra income, it would also support demand for local businesses.
However, there is a real risk of conflict with economic growth. A higher top rate of income tax reduces the reward for working longer hours, taking promotion, investing or starting a business. Some highly skilled workers, such as doctors and engineers, might move abroad, which would reduce the economy's productive capacity and the government's tax revenue. Over ten years, growth of 2.6% a year raises output by about 29%, compared with about 21% at 1.9% a year, so slower growth would mean lower incomes and less tax revenue to pay for the public services that low-income families rely on. More generous benefits could also reduce the incentive for some people to look for work.
Overall, I think Country X should give reducing inequality a higher priority than it does now, because the data show that its faster growth has left the poorest 10% worse off than the poorest in Country Y. However, it should not ignore growth: a modest rise in the top tax rate, with the revenue targeted at low-income families and at education and training, is less likely to damage incentives than a large one. The right balance depends on how strongly high earners respond to higher taxes, how well the extra revenue is spent, and on other differences between the two countries that Figure 1 does not show.
Explanation
This question tests the conflict between reducing inequality and economic growth. A Level 3 answer uses Figure 1 to show both sides - Country X's faster growth and higher GDP per capita, but its higher inequality and poorer bottom 10% - explains the incentive effects of higher taxes and benefits, and reaches a judgement that says what it depends on. Answers that use only one side of the data, or none of it, cannot go above 6 marks.