Tarnside Engineering Ltd makes parts for wind turbines. It has £2 million of retained profit in a bank deposit account. It is considering buying a new £3 million robotic production line, which it would pay for with its savings and a £1 million bank loan. Over the past year the interest rates on both business loans and business deposits have fallen from 7% to 4% a year.
Using the information, explain two ways in which the fall in interest rates may affect Tarnside Engineering's decisions to save, borrow or invest.
Model answer
First, the fall in interest rates makes borrowing cheaper. Tarnside needs a £1 million loan to buy the robotic production line, and the annual interest on it falls from £70 000 at 7% to £40 000 at 4%. Because the cost of financing the investment is now £30 000 a year lower, the extra profit from the production line is more likely to exceed the cost of the loan, so Tarnside is more likely to borrow and invest.
Second, saving becomes less rewarding. Tarnside's £2 million of retained profit earned £140 000 a year in interest at 7%, but only £80 000 at 4%. The opportunity cost of taking the money out of the bank and spending it on the production line has therefore fallen by £60 000 a year, so the business is more likely to stop saving and use its retained profit to invest.
Explanation
Each explanation needs a clear chain: what happens to the cost of borrowing or the reward for saving, why that changes the decision, and evidence from the case (the £1 million loan, the £2 million savings, the fall from 7% to 4%). The two ways must be different - cheaper loans and lower returns on savings are different effects. Working out the interest figures is a strong way to apply the answer to the context.