Practise 18 exam-style questions on Government income and expenditure for AQA GCSE Economics (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.
18 questions
1–15 marks each
Instant marking
No sign-up needed
18 questions, marked as you go
Sample questions with model answers
Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.
Question 1
1 mark
Which of the following is the largest area of UK government spending?
Choose your answer.
A Defence
B Education
C Social protection, including the state pension and welfare benefits
D Transport
Model answer
C Social protection, including the state pension and welfare benefits
Explanation
Social protection - the state pension and welfare benefits such as Universal Credit - is the largest area of UK government spending, followed by health (mainly the NHS) and then education. Defence and transport each take a much smaller share. The state pension is the largest single benefit, which is why an ageing population puts pressure on government spending.
Mark scheme
1 mark
C / Social protection, including the state pension and welfare benefits
accept the letter or the option text. If more than one option is given, 0 marks.
Question 2
2 marks
Explain what is meant by a proportional tax.
Model answer
A proportional tax takes the same percentage of income from everyone, whatever their income. A person earning £20 000 and a person earning £80 000 would both pay, say, 10% of their income in tax, so the richer person pays more in pounds but the same proportion.
Explanation
Compare it with the other two types: a progressive tax takes a larger percentage from higher incomes and a regressive tax a smaller percentage. For 2 marks you must make clear that the percentage is of income and stays the same whatever the level of income. Saying 'everyone pays the same amount' is wrong: a fixed amount is regressive.
Mark scheme
1 mark
The same rate / percentage of tax is paid by everyone / a flat-rate tax
Partial explanation (1 mark), e.g. 'everyone pays the same rate of tax', 'a flat-rate tax'. Do not credit 'everyone pays the same amount of tax' (a fixed amount takes a larger share of a lower income, so it is regressive): 0 marks.
1 mark
Completes it: of their income, whatever the level of income / the share of income paid in tax stays the same as income rises
Complete explanation (2 marks), e.g. 'a tax where people pay the same percentage of their income in tax whatever they earn'; 'as income rises, the amount of tax rises but the proportion of income paid stays the same'. An example on its own (e.g. 'a 10% tax') is not an explanation and scores 0.
Question 3
2 marks
Priya earns £48 000 a year. Assume that in one year she pays:
£7200 in income tax £2880 in National Insurance contributions £1900 in VAT on the goods and services she buys.
Calculate the percentage of Priya's income that she pays in direct taxes.
Model answer
Direct taxes = income tax + National Insurance contributions = £7200 + £2880 = £10 080 Percentage of income = £10 080 ÷ £48 000 × 100 = 21%
Explanation
Income tax and National Insurance contributions are direct taxes, paid on income; VAT is an indirect tax on spending, so it must be left out. Including VAT gives 25.0%, and using income tax alone gives 15%. Always divide by income, because the question asks for a percentage of income.
Mark scheme
1 mark
Correct method: (£7200 + £2880) ÷ £48 000 × 100 = £10 080 ÷ £48 000 × 100; or a correct final answer of 21% with no working
An answer of 21% with no working scores 2 marks. Award this mark for the correct total of direct taxes (£10 080).
1 mark
21%
Accept 21 or 21.0 with or without the % sign. 25% or 25.0% (VAT wrongly included as a direct tax): 1 mark. 15% (income tax only) or 6% (National Insurance only): 1 mark. Correct method with an arithmetic slip: 1 mark.
Question 4
6 marks
A government needs to raise an extra £10 billion of tax revenue a year.
Explain two reasons why the government might choose to raise this revenue by increasing indirect taxes rather than income tax.
Model answer
First, raising income tax reduces the reward for working. If workers keep less of each extra pound they earn, some may choose to work fewer hours, turn down overtime or not seek promotion, and highly skilled workers may even move abroad. This could reduce the number of hours worked and slow economic growth. An increase in an indirect tax such as VAT taxes spending rather than earnings, so it has a smaller direct effect on the incentive to work.
Second, indirect taxes are harder to avoid. Everyone who buys the goods pays the tax, including tourists, people living on savings and people who work in the hidden economy and do not declare their income. Because the tax is collected by sellers and included in the price, the government can raise the extra £10 billion from a very wide group of people, and the revenue is fairly reliable, especially if the tax falls on goods with price inelastic demand such as fuel.
Explanation
Each reason should explain why the indirect tax is better than income tax for this purpose, not just describe an indirect tax. Strong answers use concepts such as incentives to work, the tax base, price inelastic demand or negative externalities. Note that the reasons must be different: two points about avoidance count as one.
Mark scheme
3 marks
First reason, e.g. a higher income tax rate reduces the reward for working, so some people may work fewer hours or not take promotions, whereas an indirect tax does not tax earnings directly. 3 = a full and precise explanation applying economic concepts and issues; 2 = a partial explanation applying economic concepts and issues but lacking detail; 1 = fragmented points made; 0 = nothing worthy of credit.
Max 3 if both explanations make the same point. Possible answers include: income tax reduces the incentive to work (and to take extra hours or promotions), but indirect taxes tax spending, not earnings; indirect taxes are paid by everyone who buys the goods, including tourists, students and people working in the hidden economy, so they are harder to avoid; taxes on goods such as tobacco, alcohol or sugary drinks raise revenue while also reducing consumption of harmful goods (negative externalities / demerit goods); demand for goods such as fuel or tobacco is price inelastic, so the tax raises a reliable amount of revenue; indirect taxes are included in prices, so they are less noticeable and may be less unpopular; taxing spending rather than income encourages saving. Note: this indicative content is not exhaustive; credit other creditworthy responses.
3 marks
Second, different reason, e.g. indirect taxes are paid by everyone who buys the goods, including tourists and people who avoid income tax, so they are harder to avoid and spread the burden widely. 3 = a full and precise explanation applying economic concepts and issues; 2 = a partial explanation applying economic concepts and issues but lacking detail; 1 = fragmented points made; 0 = nothing worthy of credit.
Credit any valid reason that is different from the first. 2 marks: a reason with a partial explanation, e.g. 'income tax puts people off working'. 1 mark: fragmented points such as 'VAT raises lots of money'. Do not credit 'indirect taxes are fairer' unless it is explained (they are usually regressive).
Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.
Ctrl + Enter to check
Study HelperHints first, answers after you try
Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.