Figure 1 - A multinational car maker in the UK
Kaito Motors (an invented business) is a Japanese multinational company. It owns a large car factory in north-east England, which it opened more than 20 years ago. The UK government gave it a grant to help pay for a new production line for electric cars.
The factory buys parts from many UK suppliers, and most of the cars it makes are exported. Profits made by the factory are sent to the company's shareholders, many of whom live in Japan. The company has said that it could move production to another country if its costs in the UK rise. The table shows data for the factory (invented data).
Using Figure 1, assess whether multinational companies such as Kaito Motors benefit the UK economy.
Model answer
Figure 1 suggests that Kaito Motors brings large benefits to the UK economy. It employs 6 000 workers directly and supports an estimated 18 000 more jobs at UK suppliers, so 24 000 jobs depend on it, in a region that may otherwise have high unemployment. These workers spend their wages in local shops and services, creating further jobs through the multiplier effect. As 75% of the factory's cars are exported, it adds to UK output and economic growth, and the government receives tax on wages and spending. Multinationals also bring new technology and methods, such as electric car production, which UK workers and suppliers learn from, raising productivity.
However, there are drawbacks. The factory sent £250 million of profit to the parent company in Japan last year, so not all the income it creates stays in the UK. The company has said it could move production abroad if its UK costs rise. Because multinationals can move between countries, the UK depends on decisions made elsewhere: if the factory closed, up to 24 000 jobs could be at risk in one region, causing structural unemployment that would be hard to solve. The government also paid a £40 million grant, which has an opportunity cost, as the money could have been spent on schools or hospitals.
Overall, I think multinationals like Kaito Motors do benefit the UK economy, because the jobs, exports, tax revenue and skills they create are much larger than the profits sent abroad or the cost of the grant. However, the size of the benefit depends on how long the company stays and how much it uses UK suppliers. The risk that it could leave means the UK should avoid relying too heavily on one firm in a region, and the grant is only good value if it keeps the factory in the UK for many years.
Explanation
A Level 3 answer uses the data on both sides: 6 000 direct and 18 000 supplier jobs and 75% of output exported against £250 million of profit sent abroad, the £40 million grant and the risk of the company leaving. The judgement should weigh these and say what the answer depends on, such as how long the company stays. One-sided answers are capped at 6 marks.