Question 1
4 marksSource A: From a memorandum written for President Johnson on 13 January 1967 by Walt Rostow, his adviser on national security. Rostow based it on the reports of US officials and intelligence agencies, which relied heavily on Chinese radio broadcasts and wall posters. It was published by the US government in 1998.
The stubborn stalemate between Mao and his opponents persists after the struggle's most convulsive week yet:
1. While reports of breakdown in public order involving violence in a dozen major cities may be exaggerated, both Peking and provincial radios have confirmed widespread disorder. Peking is urging striking workers to return to their jobs, and fear is expressed of potentially serious damage to the economy. ...
3. The week saw the first really earnest attempt by Premier Chou En-Lai [Zhou Enlai] to moderate activities of the Red Guards and to protect several top leaders from their wrath. ...
4. The provincial party apparatus, believed overwhelmingly to support Mao's chief opponents, apparently remains intact (with only Shanghai in doubt) after the most determined attacks to date against it. ...
The basic fact of the matter is that all of the problems undermining Mao's position remain - fragmented and embittered leaders, - revisionist and indolent cadre, - policy and personal differences in every major element of the society, - a long list of failures in domestic and foreign policies, and - a populace as a whole which must by now be bone weary of 17 years of incessant ideological floggings.
Give two things you can infer from Source A about the situation in China in January 1967.
Set out your answer under these headings, once for each inference:
What I can infer:
Details in the source that tell me this:
Model answer
What I can infer: Public order was breaking down in many cities, and the disorder was starting to damage the economy.
Details in the source that tell me this: Radios confirmed 'widespread disorder' with violence in 'a dozen major cities', and Peking was 'urging striking workers to return to their jobs' for fear of 'serious damage to the economy'.
What I can infer: Some leaders thought the Red Guards had gone too far, and even senior figures needed protecting from them.
Details in the source that tell me this: Zhou Enlai made 'the first really earnest attempt ... to moderate activities of the Red Guards' and 'to protect several top leaders from their wrath'.
Explanation
Top answers draw conclusions about China in January 1967 from the memorandum's details, for example that Zhou's attempt to protect leaders shows the Red Guards were beyond easy control, and quote precisely. Copying a phrase such as 'widespread disorder' is not an inference. Keep to what Source A suggests rather than retelling the January Storm from own knowledge.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid inference about the situation in China in January 1967, e.g. order was breaking down in many cities / the economy was threatened as workers went on strike / some leaders were trying to rein in the Red Guards, who were out of control / senior leaders needed protection from the Red Guards / the attack on the Party in the provinces had largely failed so far / the leadership was deeply divided / many people were tired of political campaigns / reliable information was hard to obtain.
Award 1 mark for each valid inference up to a maximum of two inferences. The second mark for each example should be awarded for supporting detail selected from the source. e.g. Order had broken down in many cities (1). 'Breakdown in public order involving violence in a dozen major cities'; 'widespread disorder' confirmed by radio (1). The economy was being damaged by strikes (1). 'Peking is urging striking workers to return to their jobs'; fear of 'serious damage to the economy' (1). Some leaders believed the Red Guards had gone too far and were trying to restrain them (1). Zhou made an 'earnest attempt ... to moderate activities of the Red Guards' (1). Even top leaders were in danger from the Red Guards (1). Zhou tried 'to protect several top leaders from their wrath' (1). The attack on the provincial Party committees had largely failed so far (1). The provincial apparatus 'apparently remains intact (with only Shanghai in doubt) after the most determined attacks' (1). The leadership was split and neither side could win (1). 'The stubborn stalemate between Mao and his opponents'; 'fragmented and embittered leaders' (1). Ordinary people were tired of constant political campaigns (1). 'A populace ... bone weary of 17 years of incessant ideological floggings' (1). Accurate information was hard to get, even for the US government (1). Reports 'may be exaggerated'; the leaders 'apparently' remain; information came from radios (1). An inference must go beyond what the source says: 'there was disorder in a dozen cities' copied or reworded is a paraphrase. Own knowledge (e.g. 'the January Storm overthrew the Shanghai Party committee') is not an inference from Source A. Comments on the reliability of the memorandum are not inferences, but an inference about how hard it was to know what was happening, drawn from the source's own cautious wording, is valid. Accept other appropriate alternatives.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the first inference, e.g. 'breakdown in public order involving violence in a dozen major cities' / 'widespread disorder' / 'striking workers' / 'serious damage to the economy' / 'moderate activities of the Red Guards' / 'protect several top leaders from their wrath' / 'remains intact (with only Shanghai in doubt)' / 'stubborn stalemate' / 'fragmented and embittered leaders' / 'bone weary of 17 years of incessant ideological floggings'.
Award only if the first inference has been credited and the detail genuinely supports it (a short quotation or a close reference to Source A). A detail that does not support the inference given, or information from own knowledge, earns no mark.
-
1 mark
A second valid inference about the situation in China in January 1967, different from the first (see the examples under the first inference).
The second inference must be a different point, not the first reworded (e.g. 'there was disorder in the cities' and 'there was violence in many cities' are the same inference). Apply the same rules: no credit for paraphrase or own knowledge.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the second inference.
Award only if the second inference has been credited and the detail from Source A supports it. The same detail may support two different inferences only if it genuinely shows both.