Question 1
4 marksSource B: From a memorandum by Ralph Clough, the new Director of the Office of Chinese Affairs in the US State Department, 20 June 1957. Clough was summarising the official version of Mao's speech of 27 February 1957, 'On the Correct Handling of Contradictions among the People', which the Chinese government released on 18 June 1957. It was published by the US government in 1986.
Mao devotes considerable space to the policy of "letting a hundred flowers blossom and a hundred schools of thought contend". ... Mao also advances the thesis that more discussion of ideas is needed to strengthen the ideological hold of the Communist Party. ... But he warns that the "hundred flowers" policy does not give "counter-revolutionaries and wreckers of the socialist cause" freedom to advance "non-Marxist ideas". This danger is dealt with easily. "We simply deprive them of their freedom of speech".
To enable people to distinguish between bad ideas and good ones Mao supplies six criteria. The gist of these is that words and actions which support the regime and the Communist bloc as a whole are "fragrant flowers"; those which hinder are "poisonous weeds".
Source C: From a secret study by the CIA's Office of Current Intelligence, 'The Chinese Communist Party and the Intellectuals', dated 18 June 1958. It was a working paper for US intelligence officers. It was released by the CIA in 2009.
Neither of Mao's speeches [of February and March 1957] included the criteria for acceptable criticism--which in fact cut off free discussion--that appeared in the later published version of the February speech. ...
Many intellectuals, while correctly believing that Mao's "hundred flowers" policy had not been designed as a trap, failed to realize that Mao had not anticipated fundamental criticism of the party. ... The CCP propaganda department tried to conceal Mao's original miscalculation by encouraging the view that a trap had been laid for the intellectuals.
Interpretation 1: From Within Limits: Speech and Silence in Mao's China by Dermot Stainton (fictional), published in 1993.
The Hundred Flowers never offered real freedom of speech. Mao had always said that the flowers must help socialism, and the Party kept control of every newspaper, publisher and university. Intellectuals had not forgotten the arrest of the writer Hu Feng in 1955, and most of them stayed silent through 1956 because they knew the risks. Even in 1957 criticism was invited at forums organised by the Party itself. When Mao's speech on 'contradictions' was published in June 1957, it set out rules for telling 'fragrant flowers' from 'poisonous weeds', and the critics who had spoken out were soon made to pay for it. Speech was free only for those who said what the Party wanted to hear.
Interpretation 2: From Six Weeks of Spring: Criticism in China, 1957 by Edith Wythburn (fictional), published in 2009.
For a few weeks in May and June 1957 Chinese people spoke more freely than at any other time under communist rule. Students at Peking University covered a 'Democracy Wall' with posters, and leaders of the democratic parties attacked the Party in public: the editor Chu Anping accused it of treating the whole country as its own property, and the newspapers printed his words. Mao's speeches of February and March had set no clear limits, and many critics believed that he meant what he said. The rules that ruled out attacks on socialism and on the Party's leadership were added only when his speech was published in June, after the People's Daily had begun the counter-attack on 8 June.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how much freedom of speech there was during the Hundred Flowers campaign (1956-57). You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different evidence about Mao's speech of February 1957. Interpretation 1 argues that the campaign 'never offered real freedom of speech', pointing to the published version of the speech, which set out rules for telling 'fragrant flowers' from 'poisonous weeds'. This is supported by Source B, which shows that the published speech said more discussion was meant 'to strengthen the ideological hold of the Communist Party', denied freedom to 'wreckers of the socialist cause' and even said 'We simply deprive them of their freedom of speech'. Interpretation 2, however, argues that Mao's speeches of February and March 'had set no clear limits' and that the rules 'were added only when his speech was published in June'. This is supported by Source C, in which the CIA found that 'neither of Mao's speeches' included 'the criteria for acceptable criticism', which appeared only in 'the later published version'. A historian relying on the published speech would see limits that were there all along; one who knew that it had been revised would see a few weeks of real freedom in 1957.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason, here that the historians rely on different evidence about Mao's speech or look at different periods of the campaign, and support it by matching details in Sources B and C to claims in each interpretation. The key point is that the published version of the speech (Source B) contained limits that, according to the CIA, were not in what Mao said in February and March 1957 (Source C). Simply saying that one historian is biased stays in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 1: in the published version of Mao's speech, more discussion is meant 'to strengthen the ideological hold of the Communist Party', the policy does not give 'counter-revolutionaries and wreckers of the socialist cause' freedom to advance 'non-Marxist ideas', Mao says 'We simply deprive them of their freedom of speech', and 'six criteria' separate the 'fragrant flowers' (words that support the regime) from the 'poisonous weeds'; this matches Interpretation 1's view that the flowers had to 'help socialism', that the published speech set out rules for telling the two apart, and that speech was free 'only for those who said what the Party wanted to hear'. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 2: the CIA found that 'neither of Mao's speeches' of February and March 1957 included 'the criteria for acceptable criticism', which 'in fact cut off free discussion' and appeared only in 'the later published version', and that many intellectuals believed the policy 'had not been designed as a trap'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that Mao's speeches 'had set no clear limits', that 'many critics believed that he meant what he said', and that the rules 'were added only when his speech was published in June'. A student may note that a historian who relies on the published speech (Source B) sees limits that were there all along, while one who knows that the speech was revised (Source C) sees a short period of real freedom before the limits were imposed. The interpretations may also differ because of a different focus or period: Interpretation 1 looks at the whole campaign, including the cautious year of 1956, the Party's control of the press and of the forums, and what happened to the critics afterwards; Interpretation 2 concentrates on a few weeks in May and June 1957 (the Democracy Wall, Chu Anping's speech). Level 2 needs an explained reason supported by details from the interpretations (and, if used, matched details from the sources). Do not credit answers that only describe the difference, reasons based only on publication dates or titles, or bare assertions of bias.