Question 1
4 marksSource B: An account written for this course, based on descriptions that workers in Shanghai factories later gave of their feelings about Mao in 1967-68.
Every morning before our shift, the whole workshop gathered in front of Chairman Mao's portrait to 'ask for instructions', and every evening we 'reported back'. The factory gave each of us a badge, and I bought more with my own money; my wife sewed a red cover for my Quotations. When the radio announced a new instruction from the Chairman, even late at night, we went out into the streets with drums and gongs to celebrate. I was not pretending. Before Liberation my father had pulled a rickshaw and died young. Under Chairman Mao I had a steady job, a room for my family and free treatment at the factory clinic. To me he was the man who had given us a decent life.
Source C: From the 'Regulations on strengthening public security work in the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution', issued jointly by the Central Committee of the CCP and the State Council (China's government) on 13 January 1967 (translated for this course). They became known as the 'Six Articles on Public Security'. Lin Biao was Minister of Defence and, from August 1966, the CCP's only Vice-Chairman.
The public security organs are one of the important tools of the dictatorship of the proletariat and must ... strengthen the dictatorship over the enemy, protect the democratic rights of the people ... For this purpose, the following regulations are made: ...
(2) All those who send counter-revolutionary anonymous letters, secretly or openly put up or hand out counter-revolutionary leaflets, write reactionary slogans or shout reactionary slogans in order to attack and slander the great leader Chairman Mao and his close comrade-in-arms Comrade Lin Biao are committing active counter-revolutionary acts and must be punished according to law. ...
(5) Those who use the great democracy, or other means, to spread reactionary views are, in general, to be struggled against by the revolutionary masses. In serious cases, the public security departments, working together with the revolutionary masses, must investigate promptly and, where necessary, deal with them as appropriate. ...
These regulations must be publicised widely among the masses ... These regulations may be posted up widely in towns and countryside.
Interpretation 1: From The Red Sun Rising: Popular Feeling in the Cultural Revolution by Agnes Shuttleworth (fictional), published in 1979.
It would be a mistake to see the worship of Mao in the late 1960s as nothing more than a performance. For millions of ordinary Chinese, love for the Chairman was real. Workers and peasants remembered how Mao's victory had ended years of war, foreign invasion and hunger, and they gave him the credit for the land, jobs, schools and clinics that followed. When they carried the Quotations, wore his badges and celebrated his latest instructions, most did so willingly. For a people used to honouring emperors, it was not hard to see Mao as a great and wise father of the nation.
Interpretation 2: From Performing Loyalty: Fear and Ritual in Mao's China by Victor Prendergast (fictional), published in 2011.
By 1967 devotion to Mao was compulsory, and everyone knew it. Bowing to his portrait, reciting quotations and dancing 'loyalty dances' became part of the daily routine in schools, factories and offices. To criticise Mao was a crime, and even an accident, such as tearing a newspaper with his picture on it, could lead to accusations of being a counter-revolutionary. People, especially those from 'bad' class backgrounds, competed to show their loyalty because it was the safest way to protect themselves and their families. Many who wept in public at the mention of the Chairman kept their doubts to themselves.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how genuine the devotion to Mao was in the years 1966-69. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, in which a Shanghai worker says 'I was not pretending', bought badges 'with my own money' and gives Mao the credit for 'a steady job, a room for my family and free treatment at the factory clinic'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that 'love for the Chairman was real' because workers and peasants gave Mao 'the credit for the land, jobs, schools and clinics' they had gained, so 'most did so willingly'. The author of Interpretation 2 seems to have relied on evidence like Source C, the regulations of January 1967, which made it an 'active counter-revolutionary' act to 'attack and slander the great leader Chairman Mao' and ordered the rules to be 'posted up widely in towns and countryside'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that 'To criticise Mao was a crime' and that people showed loyalty 'to protect themselves'.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details: the worker's gratitude for his job and home in Source B with Interpretation 1, and the law punishing attacks on Mao in Source C with Interpretation 2's argument about fear. Weaker answers simply say which source each historian 'used', or describe the difference again instead of explaining it. Reasons based on dates or on a historian's assumed bias are not valid unless they are linked to the evidence each used.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: the worker says 'I was not pretending', bought extra badges 'with my own money', celebrated new instructions 'even late at night', and gives Mao the credit for 'a steady job, a room for my family and free treatment at the factory clinic', contrasting this with his father's life as a rickshaw puller before 1949; this matches Interpretation 1's view that 'love for the Chairman was real', that workers and peasants gave Mao 'the credit for the land, jobs, schools and clinics' and that 'most did so willingly'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: the regulations of January 1967 made attacking or slandering 'the great leader Chairman Mao and his close comrade-in-arms Comrade Lin Biao' an 'active counter-revolutionary' act to be 'punished according to law', called for people spreading 'reactionary views' to be 'struggled against' and investigated, and were to be 'posted up widely in towns and countryside' so that everyone knew; this matches Interpretation 2's view that 'To criticise Mao was a crime', that devotion was 'compulsory, and everyone knew it', and that people showed loyalty 'to protect themselves'. A student may note that Source B also shows that the rituals were organised by the workplace ('the whole workshop gathered', 'The factory gave each of us a badge'), which a historian like the author of Interpretation 2 could use as evidence of compulsion, and that it is based on recollections given years later. The interpretations may also differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 concentrates on workers and peasants who had gained from the revolution, while Interpretation 2 looks at the pressures of daily life and at people from 'bad' class backgrounds who had most to fear. They may differ in approach: Interpretation 1 explains devotion by gratitude and tradition, Interpretation 2 by the laws and pressures that made public displays of loyalty necessary; public behaviour alone cannot show what people privately believed. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 2 used Source C' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view without explaining it, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication unless the answer shows how this affected the evidence available, or an assertion that one historian is biased.