Question 1
4 marksSource B: An account written for this course, based on descriptions that foreign residents gave of how the cities of east China were governed in the months after the PLA took them over in 1949.
When the PLA marched into the city, a Military Control Commission took charge. Its chairman was a senior PLA commander, and its members were mostly army officers and political commissars. The Commission took over the city government, the police, the banks and the newspapers, and it sent army representatives into the main factories and public utilities. All orders were issued in its name and published in the newspapers, and foreigners had to apply to it for permission to travel. Above the cities, the whole region was run by a committee of the army's senior commanders and political commissars. For the first year, it was soldiers who governed.
Source C: From National Intelligence Estimate 13-56, a secret report on Communist China prepared by the US intelligence agencies for the US government, dated 5 January 1956. In 1949-54 China had been divided into six large regions, four of them governed by military and administrative committees. Kao Kang (Gao Gang), the Party leader in the North-East, had been purged in 1954. The report was later published by the US government.
23. Although the prestige of the army and the role of its leaders remain great, the direct role of the army in planning and policy has been steadily curtailed, particularly since the dissolution of the regional governments in 1952-1954. The newly created National Defense Council appears to be largely an advisory body less powerful than its predecessor, the People's Revolutionary Military Council. Control of most of the internal security forces has been taken away from the armed forces and placed under the Minister of Public Security. ...
24. ... It is possible that there may have been some sympathy among military commanders for the alleged belief of Kao Kang that 'the party was created by the army' ... However, the high party status of many military commanders gives them a vested interest in the regime, and the long established system of political officers within the army provides a constant check on the activities of military leaders.
Interpretation 1: From Soldiers in Office: The PLA and the New State by Clive Rushworth (fictional), published in 1980.
In its first years the People's Republic was ruled by its army. The cities were governed by military control commissions, and four of the six great regions into which China was divided were run by military and administrative committees led by commanders such as Peng Dehuai, Lin Biao and Liu Bocheng. Soldiers carried out land reform, hunted down bandits and GMD supporters, and many officers became local officials. The PLA had won the war, and for several years it was the PLA, more than the civilian Party, that held China together.
Interpretation 2: From Party Before Army: Civil Control in the People's Republic by Louisa Fenwright (fictional), published in 2009.
The PLA was always the Party's army. Every unit had its political commissar and its Party committee, and the commanders who governed the regions after 1949 were themselves senior Party members who took their orders from the Politburo. Mao, as chairman of the military council, kept final control. The regional governments were temporary: once order was restored they were abolished in 1954, and the army's role in government was steadily reduced. Gao Gang's fall showed what happened to a leader who seemed to put his own power base before the Party.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the role of the PLA in governing China in the years 1949-54. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason the interpretations differ is that they focus on different stages of the period. Interpretation 1 concentrates on the first years after 1949, when the army was most visible in government. It says that 'cities were governed by military control commissions' and that regions were 'run by military and administrative committees led by commanders'. Source B describes exactly this early stage: a Military Control Commission chaired by the army commander took over the city's government, police and banks, so that 'For the first year, it was soldiers who governed'.
Interpretation 2 looks at the whole period up to 1954 and at who held final control. It argues that the regions 'were abolished in 1954' and that the army's role 'was steadily reduced', and that commanders were 'senior Party members' checked by political commissars. Source C, written in 1956, supports this: it says the army's role 'has been steadily curtailed' since 'the dissolution of the regional governments in 1952-1954', and that 'the long established system of political officers within the army provides a constant check' on its leaders.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason, such as a different focus in time (the military rule of 1949-50 v. the Party's control by 1954) or the use of different evidence, and support it by matching details in the sources to claims in the interpretations. Weaker answers repeat the difference between the interpretations or simply say they 'used different sources' without showing which details fit which view.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 1: it describes the city governed by a 'Military Control Commission' chaired by the army commander and staffed by officers and commissars, taking over the government, police, banks and newspapers, with the region 'run by a committee of the army's senior commanders', so that 'it was soldiers who governed'; this matches Interpretation 1's 'cities were governed by military control commissions', regions 'run by military and administrative committees led by commanders' and its view that the PLA held China together. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 2: it says 'the direct role of the army in planning and policy has been steadily curtailed', especially after 'the dissolution of the regional governments in 1952-1954', that military commanders had 'high party status' and that 'the long established system of political officers within the army provides a constant check' on military leaders; this matches Interpretation 2's 'political commissar' and 'Party committee' in every unit, commanders who were 'senior Party members', regions that 'were abolished in 1954' and an army role 'steadily reduced'. Source C's reference to Gao Gang's alleged belief that 'the party was created by the army' could also be linked to Interpretation 2's comment on his fall. The interpretations may also differ because of a different focus or timescale: Interpretation 1 looks at 1949-50, when military rule was at its height, while Interpretation 2 looks at the whole period to 1954 and at where final authority lay; or because they use different criteria: who carried out government (Interpretation 1) v. who controlled the army (Interpretation 2). Note that Source B was written for this course, so a student should treat it as an illustration of the kind of evidence a historian might use. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported from the interpretations (and, if used, matched to details in the sources). Answers that only say 'they used different sources' or repeat the difference of view stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication.