Question 1
4 marksSource B: From the report by Liu Shaoqi, Vice-Chairman of the Central People's Government, explaining the draft Agrarian Reform Law to the National Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference on 14 June 1950. Here he describes the land reform carried out in parts of North China and Honan in the winter of 1949-50, before the Agrarian Reform Law was passed. This official English translation was published in Peking by the Foreign Languages Press in 1950. Honan is now written Henan.
Last winter, the People's Government carried out and completed, or in the main completed, agrarian reform in the suburbs of the cities and in a number of other areas in North China and in half the area of Honan Province involving a total rural population of 26 million.
Generally speaking, no serious deviations occurred in the course of carrying out the agrarian reform last winter. It was carried out quite smoothly and very few disruptive incidents took place. The people, especially the peasants who have been given land and other means of production, are satisfied with this agrarian reform. ...
The results of agrarian reform are beneficial to the impoverished labouring peasants, helping the peasants partly solve their problem of poverty. ... The mere carrying out of agrarian reform can only solve part, but not the whole, of the problem of the peasants' poverty.
Source C: From a secret telegram sent to the US Secretary of State by the US Consul General in Hong Kong on 20 April 1951. The USA had no diplomats in the People's Republic of China, so the Consul General gathered information from people coming out of China. The telegram is written in shortened 'telegram English': 'ConGen' means the Consul General's office, 'Amer' American, 'fon' foreign, 'Commie' Communist, 'Chi' Chinese and 'econ' economic. It was published by the US government in 1983.
ConGen sources for info requested primarily Amer missionaries other fon observers and anti Commie Chi. Great majority these persons strongly anti-Commie and have relatively little contact with groups most likely to be favorably inclined toward Commie regime. ...
6. Peasants.
Sources inadequate since most ConGen informants principal contact with landlords rather than poor peasants farm laborer group. ... Current land reform believed engendering more opposition than support because followed by excessive taxes, disruption rural econ system, interference with peasant custom and conscription. Those receiving land more often than not worse off than before and cost of Korean war tends to compel increase rather than decrease of tax pressure.
Interpretation 1: From The Year the Land Changed Hands by Lavinia Copplestone (fictional), published in 1979.
For hundreds of millions of poor peasants, land reform was the greatest change of their lives. Around 300 million people received land, and with it draught animals, tools and houses taken from the landlords. Rents, which had often taken half the harvest, were abolished, and so were many old debts. Peasants held title deeds to land of their own for the first time. With the civil war over and the land in their hands, families worked harder and harvests recovered quickly: by 1952 grain output was far above the level of 1949. Many villagers later described land reform as the moment when they had 'turned over' (fanshen) and stood up to those who had once ruled them.
Interpretation 2: From Small Plots, Heavy Burdens by Barnaby Strickland (fictional), published in 2008.
The gains of land reform for ordinary peasants were real but smaller than the Party claimed. There was simply not enough land in China to make the poor prosperous: most families ended up with a holding of only a hectare or so, too small to escape poverty in a bad year, and many lacked the animals and tools to farm it. Taxes in grain rose to help pay for the Korean War, and the new village cadres could be as demanding as the landlords had been. Families labelled 'middle peasants' feared that they would be the next targets. Within two or three years some poor peasants were already selling their land or borrowing again, which was one reason why the Party soon pushed them into mutual aid teams.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how far peasants benefited from land reform in the years 1950-52. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, in which Liu Shaoqi says that land reform was carried out 'quite smoothly' and that 'the peasants who have been given land and other means of production, are satisfied', and that its results 'are beneficial to the impoverished labouring peasants'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that land reform was 'the greatest change' in peasants' lives, giving them land, animals, tools and title deeds and ending rents. The author of Interpretation 2 seems closer to evidence like Source C, in which the US Consul General reports that land reform was 'engendering more opposition than support' because of 'excessive taxes' and that those who received land were 'more often than not worse off than before', with the Korean War increasing 'tax pressure'. This matches Interpretation 2's view that the gains were 'smaller than the Party claimed' and that 'Taxes in grain rose to help pay for the Korean War'.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details: Liu's 'satisfied' peasants with Interpretation 1, and the Consul General's 'excessive taxes' and peasants 'worse off than before' with Interpretation 2. Good answers may also point out that the sources themselves come from very different viewpoints. Simply saying which source each historian 'used', or describing the difference again, stays in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 1: Liu Shaoqi claims that land reform in North China in 1949-50 was carried out 'quite smoothly', with 'no serious deviations', that 'the peasants who have been given land and other means of production, are satisfied', and that the results 'are beneficial to the impoverished labouring peasants'; this matches Interpretation 1's view that peasants 'received land ... draught animals, tools and houses', that rents and debts were abolished and that land reform was 'the greatest change of their lives'. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 2: the US Consul General reports that land reform was 'engendering more opposition than support' because of 'excessive taxes', disruption and conscription, that 'Those receiving land more often than not worse off than before' and that the Korean War meant an 'increase rather than decrease of tax pressure'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that gains were 'smaller than the Party claimed', that 'Taxes in grain rose to help pay for the Korean War' and that peasants soon fell back into debt. A student may note that Source B was an official report designed to win approval for the draft law, while Source C admits that its informants were 'strongly anti-Commie' and mainly in contact 'with landlords rather than poor peasants', so a historian who relied on one rather than the other could reach a different view; Liu himself admits that land reform 'can only solve part' of the peasants' poverty, which an author like that of Interpretation 2 could use. The interpretations may differ because of their focus or timescale: Interpretation 1 looks at the immediate gains (land, deeds, the end of rent, the recovery of harvests by 1952), while Interpretation 2 looks at the size of holdings, taxes and what happened 'within two or three years'. They may differ because they measure benefit differently: against the misery of the years before 1949 (Interpretation 1) or against the Party's claims and the poverty that remained (Interpretation 2). Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.