Question 1
4 marksSource B: From the Resolution on Some Questions Concerning the People's Communes, adopted by the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party at a meeting in Wuchang (Wuhan) on 10 December 1958. It begins by describing how the communes had been set up. This official English translation was published on 23 December 1958 in Peking Review, a weekly magazine published in Beijing for readers abroad.
The movement to set up people's communes has grown very rapidly. Within a few months starting in the summer of 1958, all of the more than 740,000 agricultural producers' co-operatives in the country, in response to the enthusiastic demand of the mass of peasants, reorganized themselves into over 26,000 people's communes. Over 120 million households, or more than 99 per cent of all China's peasant households of various nationalities, have joined the people's communes. ...
Although the rural people's communes were established only a short while ago, the mass of the peasants are already conscious of the obvious benefits they have brought them. ... To meet the pressing demands of the masses, the communes have set up large numbers of community dining-rooms, nurseries, kindergartens, "homes of respect for the aged" and other institutions for collective welfare, which have, in particular, completely emancipated women from thousands of years of kitchen drudgery and brought broad smiles to their faces. ... the mass of peasants, both men and women, have begun to receive their wages and those families which in the past constantly worried about their daily meals ... are now able to "eat without paying."
Source C: From National Intelligence Estimate 13-2-59, 'Present Trends in Communist China', a secret report prepared for the US government by its intelligence agencies and dated 10 February 1959. The 'recent party directive' was the resolution of December 1958. The report was published by the US government in 1996.
The Chinese Communist "great leap forward" program has been based largely upon a prodigious expenditure of manpower. ...
Almost the entire countryside has been organized, in varying degrees, into communes. We believe that the recent party directive modifying the commune program, including the postponement of city communes, largely reflects the need for consolidation before pushing forward again. Although there has been considerable adverse popular reaction, there is little evidence of overt resistance. We believe that the regime's strong system of controls and demonstrated flexibility will enable Peiping to avoid either a repressive blood bath or a forced retreat from the communal experiment. ...
If the leap forward and commune innovations succeed over a period of time, they could transform China into a George Orwellian society and accelerate Communist China's progress toward becoming a major world power.
Interpretation 1: From Red Harvest: The Chinese Village in 1958 by Maribel Tollworthy (fictional), published in 1984.
In the autumn of 1958 many peasants welcomed the communes. After a good harvest, the new communal dining halls served free meals and villagers were told to eat as much as they liked. Nurseries and kindergartens allowed women to earn work points, and the poorest households, who had little to lose, were promised that the commune would look after them in old age and sickness. Party propaganda promised that communism and plenty were only a few years away, and in the excitement of the Leap many villagers, especially the young, joined its campaigns with real enthusiasm. Disillusion came later, when food began to run short in 1959.
Interpretation 2: From Fear in the Fields: Peasants and the People's Communes by Crispin Haddleton (fictional), published in 2008.
Behind the reports of enthusiasm, most peasants joined the communes because they had no choice. Communes were set up in a few weeks by Party officials, often without any real discussion in the villages. Families lost their private plots, their pigs and poultry, their tools and, in many places, their cooking pots, which were taken for the steel campaign. Many peasants slaughtered and ate their animals rather than hand them over to the commune. After the Anti-Rightist campaign of 1957, few dared to complain in public. The silence that officials took for support was, for most villagers, the silence of fear.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the attitudes of China's peasants to the people's communes in 1958. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, in which the Central Committee claims that the communes were set up 'in response to the enthusiastic demand of the mass of peasants', that the dining rooms brought women 'broad smiles' and that families could now 'eat without paying'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that peasants 'welcomed the communes', enjoying free meals and nurseries. The author of Interpretation 2 seems closer to evidence like Source C, in which US intelligence reported 'considerable adverse popular reaction' but 'little evidence of overt resistance' because of the regime's 'strong system of controls'. This matches Interpretation 2's argument that peasants joined 'because they had no choice' and that their silence was 'the silence of fear'.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching details: the Party's claims of 'enthusiastic demand' with Interpretation 1, and the US report of 'adverse popular reaction' held down by 'controls' with Interpretation 2. A different focus (the first months and particular groups against the majority and what they lost) is also a valid reason. Simply saying which source each historian 'used', or describing the difference again, stays in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: the Central Committee claims the communes were formed 'in response to the enthusiastic demand of the mass of peasants', that peasants were 'already conscious of the obvious benefits', that dining rooms and nurseries met 'the pressing demands of the masses' and brought women 'broad smiles', and that families could 'eat without paying'; this fits Interpretation 1's free meals in the dining halls, nurseries that let women earn work points and peasants who 'welcomed the communes' with 'real enthusiasm'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: US intelligence reported 'considerable adverse popular reaction' but 'little evidence of overt resistance' because of 'the regime's strong system of controls', and warned of a 'George Orwellian society'; this fits Interpretation 2's view that peasants joined 'because they had no choice', that 'few dared to complain' and that their silence was 'the silence of fear'. A student may note that Source B is the Party's own public account, written to show support, while Source C is a secret assessment by China's enemy. The interpretations may differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 looks at the first months (autumn 1958, the free meals after a good harvest) and at particular groups (the poorest, women, the young), while Interpretation 2 looks at what peasants lost (plots, animals, tools, pots) and at the majority. They may differ because they read silence differently: Interpretation 1 takes participation as support, Interpretation 2 sees it as fear. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.