Question 1
4 marksSource B: From a CIA information report, 'Moslems and Moslem Associations in Communist China', distributed to US government departments on 25 February 1955. It was based on information from an informant whose name has been removed from the released copy, covering 1952 to August 1954. Peiping was the name used by the Chinese Nationalists and the US government for Beijing. A catty is about half a kilogram.
In July 1954 there were 44 mosques in the Peiping area, which is the same number that existed prior to the occupation of the city by the Chinese Communists in February 1949. ...
In the winter of 1953, when meat could not be bought by most people in Peiping, Moslems were adequately supplied with mutton and beef. Each Moslem was rationed one catty of sesame oil a month, which was more than the general ration. This was part of the policy of the government aimed at securing the support of minority religious groups. Also, if charged with wrong-doing, a Moslem could have his punishment reduced if his Leader interceded in his behalf.
Source C: From an article in ad-Dustur, a daily newspaper in Basra, Iraq, published on 14 September 1953 and translated by the CIA for US government departments in January 1954. The newspaper belonged to a strongly anti-communist party in Iraq. The article was replying to a claim in some Arabic newspapers that Mao was of Muslim origin. Sinkiang (Xinjiang) and Turkestan refer to the Uyghur region of north-west China.
There is absolutely no basis for such a claim; for had Mao Tse-tung really been a Moslem, then how can anybody explain the large-scale persecutions carried out by his regime against China's Moslems? Judging from the reports we have, the following are but a few samples of the persecution campaign:
1. The Communist confiscation of all real estate belonging to Islamic religious institutions in Sinkiang. ...
3. The Communist outlawing of all Islamic religious instruction throughout China.
4. The Communist closing of all Moslem schools in China.
5. The Communist conversion of mosques and Islamic holy places in Turkestan, into community property, as part of the confiscation campaign against the Moslems there.
6. The Communist prevention of the holy pilgrimage to Mecca by Chinese Moslems.
Interpretation 1: From Minorities and the State in Early Communist China by Hector Glasbury (fictional), published in 1987.
In the 1950s the CCP treated China's Muslims with care. It needed the loyalty of the Hui, who lived across north-west China, and of the Uyghurs and other Muslim peoples of Xinjiang, and it wanted friends in the Muslim countries of Asia and Africa. Mosques stayed open, an official Islamic Association was founded in 1953, and Muslims received special supplies of beef and mutton so that they did not have to eat pork. The Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region was created in 1955. As long as Muslim leaders accepted the authority of the Party, their faith was respected.
Interpretation 2: From The Narrowing Path: Islam in Mao's China by Ottoline Brackenfield (fictional), published in 2016.
From the start, the CCP set out to weaken the power of Islam in China. Land reform took the lands that had supported mosques and religious schools. Imams were watched, and Muslim leaders were expected to preach the Party's line. Religious teaching was restricted, and many Muslim schools were closed or taken over by the state. When some Hui communities resisted the 'religious reform' campaign of 1958, their revolts were crushed by the army. The respect shown to Islam was a tactic for winning time, not a lasting policy.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the CCP's treatment of China's Muslims in the 1950s. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 may have relied on evidence like Source B, a CIA informant's report that Beijing still had '44 mosques' in 1954, 'the same number' as before 1949, and that when meat was scarce Muslims were 'adequately supplied with mutton and beef' as 'part of the policy of the government aimed at securing the support of minority religious groups'. This matches Interpretation 1's view that 'mosques stayed open', that Muslims received 'special supplies of beef and mutton' and that 'their faith was respected'. The author of Interpretation 2 seems closer to evidence like Source C, in which an Iraqi newspaper claims the 'confiscation of all real estate belonging to Islamic religious institutions', the 'closing of all Moslem schools' and the 'outlawing of all Islamic religious instruction'. This fits Interpretation 2's claims that land reform 'took the lands that had supported mosques and religious schools' and that Muslim schools were closed.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching specific details in the sources to specific claims in the interpretations, for example the 44 mosques and extra meat with Interpretation 1, and the confiscation of religious property and closing of schools with Interpretation 2. A strong answer may also notice that each source has a limited viewpoint: one informant in Beijing, and a hostile foreign newspaper making sweeping claims. Weaker answers simply say which source each historian used.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 1: the CIA's informant reports that Beijing still had '44 mosques' in 1954, 'the same number' as before 1949, that Muslims were 'adequately supplied with mutton and beef' and given extra oil when meat was scarce, as 'part of the policy of the government aimed at securing the support of minority religious groups', and that a Muslim leader could have a punishment reduced; this fits Interpretation 1's 'Mosques stayed open', 'special supplies of beef and mutton' and 'their faith was respected'. Source C supports Interpretation 2: the Iraqi newspaper lists the 'confiscation of all real estate belonging to Islamic religious institutions in Sinkiang', the 'outlawing of all Islamic religious instruction', the 'closing of all Moslem schools' and the conversion of mosques into 'community property'; this fits Interpretation 2's 'Land reform took the lands that had supported mosques and religious schools' and 'many Muslim schools were closed'. They may differ because of a different focus: Interpretation 1 looks at national policy and Beijing (the capital, where policy was shown to visitors), while Interpretation 2 looks at the countryside, Xinjiang and the Hui revolts of 1958. They may differ because of the period they stress: Interpretation 1 concentrates on the early 1950s, Interpretation 2 reads the early 1950s in the light of the 'religious reform' campaign of 1958. They may differ in how they judge the CCP's intentions: Interpretation 1 takes the policy of respect at face value, while Interpretation 2 sees it as 'a tactic for winning time'. A strong answer may note that Source C is a hostile foreign newspaper making sweeping claims ('all'), some of them exaggerated (for example, small official groups of Chinese Muslims made the pilgrimage to Mecca from 1955), while Source B comes from one informant in Beijing. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source B' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.