Question 1
4 marksSource B: From 'Mao's Last Hurrah: The Campaign against Teng Hsiao-ping', a secret study written in August 1976 by a member of the Office of Political Research of the US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA). The author said that other CIA offices had been consulted but that the study had not been formally agreed with them. Teng Hsiao-ping is Deng Xiaoping, who had been dismissed in April 1976. Tienanmen Square is Tiananmen Square. It was released by the CIA in 2004.
The anti-Teng campaign has demonstrated not so much the strength as the weakness of Mao's revolutionary supporters. Over the past decade, Mao has alienated in turn:
-- most of the old Party cadres (in the Cultural Revolution),
-- most of the military (in the anti-Lin Piao campaign), and
-- most of the industrial work force (in the anti-Confucian campaign).
Those actively supporting Mao in the current campaign appear to be only the ideologues (who control the media); the worker-peasant-soldier students (who control the campuses); and the young Leftist cadres who emerged during the Cultural Revolution (and who do not control much of anything). ... The most striking indication, however, was the demonstration at Tienanmen Square in Peking in early April, the first mass demonstration in China directed against Mao's leadership.
Source C: From a report to the Foreign Relations Committee of the US Senate by Senator Hugh Scott, the leader of the Republican senators, published in September 1976. Scott had visited China from 10 to 24 July 1976 as the guest of the Chinese People's Institute of Foreign Affairs. Chang Ch'un-ch'iao is Zhang Chunqiao, one of the Gang of Four. Premier Chou is Zhou Enlai, who had died in January 1976.
Teng Hsiao-p'ing was hardly mentioned to us by Foreign Minister Ch'iao Kuan-hua, by the senior Vice Premier Chang Ch'un-ch'iao, or by the Vice Chairman of the Revolutionary Committee of the Shanghai Municipality, but with almost ritualistic regularity, criticism of Teng was a part of conversations we had everywhere else, at Peking University, in factories, at a May 7th cadre school, in museums, at two communes, in hospitals, sports centers, musical performances, and even in kindergartens. ...
A power-seeking "left," speaking as ideologues and moralists, and citing Chairman Mao as their authority, was telling the people to condemn Teng Hsiao-p'ing -- the elitist, the capitalist roader, and the betrayer of the revolution. The pragmatists and the administrators, in whom Premier Chou placed great trust in his January 1975 "will and testament," were largely silent ...
Interpretation 1: From The Shanghai Radicals by Cecil Draycott (fictional), published in 1989.
From 1973 until Mao's death the Gang of Four was the most powerful group in China after Mao himself. Wang Hongwen became the Party's third-ranking leader at the Tenth Congress in 1973, Zhang Chunqiao became a Vice-Premier and head of the army's political department, and Jiang Qing and Yao Wenyuan controlled the newspapers, the radio and the arts. Through the campaign to criticise Lin Biao and Confucius they attacked Zhou Enlai, and in 1976 they turned the whole country against Deng Xiaoping. In every factory, school and commune people had to repeat their slogans.
Interpretation 2: From Paper Tigers: The Gang of Four, 1973-76 by Rowena Kettleby (fictional), published in 2013.
The Gang of Four was much weaker than its noisy propaganda suggested. Its members never controlled the government ministries, which Zhou Enlai and then Deng Xiaoping filled with experienced administrators, and they had little support among army commanders and provincial leaders. Mao himself warned them in 1974 and 1975 not to act as a 'gang of four'. When Zhou died, Mao chose Hua Guofeng, not Zhang Chunqiao, as acting Premier. Their power rested on the media and on Mao's protection, and when Mao died it collapsed within a month.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how much power the Gang of Four had in China in the years 1973-76. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
One reason is that the historians have given weight to different sources. The author of Interpretation 1 seems to have relied on evidence like Source C, in which Senator Scott found criticism of Deng repeated 'with almost ritualistic regularity' in universities, factories, communes, hospitals 'and even in kindergartens', while a 'power-seeking "left"' told 'the people to condemn Teng' and the pragmatists 'were largely silent'. This fits Interpretation 1's view that the Gang 'turned the whole country against Deng Xiaoping' and that people everywhere 'had to repeat their slogans'. The author of Interpretation 2 is closer to evidence like Source B, where the CIA concluded that the campaign showed 'the weakness' of Mao's radical supporters, who had alienated the old cadres, 'most of the military' and the workers, and controlled only 'the media' and 'the campuses'. This matches Interpretation 2's claim that the Gang had 'little support among army commanders and provincial leaders' and that its 'power rested on the media and on Mao's protection'.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason and support it by matching details: Scott's experience of the anti-Deng campaign everywhere he went with Interpretation 1, and the CIA's judgement that the radicals controlled only the media and campuses with Interpretation 2. Another valid reason is a different focus, propaganda and public campaigns against real control of the government, army and provinces. Weaker answers say which source each historian 'used' without showing the link.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B supports Interpretation 2: the CIA judged that the anti-Teng campaign showed 'not so much the strength as the weakness' of Mao's radical supporters, who had alienated 'most of the old Party cadres', 'most of the military' and 'most of the industrial work force', and who controlled only 'the media', 'the campuses' and young cadres who 'do not control much of anything'; the Tiananmen demonstration of April 1976 was 'directed against Mao's leadership'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that the Gang 'never controlled the government ministries', had 'little support among army commanders and provincial leaders' and that 'their power rested on the media and on Mao's protection'. Source C supports Interpretation 1: Scott found criticism of Deng 'with almost ritualistic regularity' in universities, factories, communes, hospitals 'and even in kindergartens', while 'a power-seeking "left"' was 'telling the people to condemn Teng' and the pragmatists 'were largely silent'; this matches Interpretation 1's claim that the Gang 'turned the whole country against Deng Xiaoping' and that 'in every factory, school and commune people had to repeat their slogans'. The interpretations may differ because of their focus: Interpretation 1 looks at the Gang's control of propaganda, campaigns and public life, Interpretation 2 at the real instruments of power (ministries, army, provinces) and at their dependence on Mao. They may differ because of the evidence used: what visitors and ordinary people saw and heard in public (as in Source C) against secret analysis of who held power (as in Source B). They may differ because Interpretation 2 uses hindsight about the Gang's rapid collapse after Mao's death. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 1 used Source C' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view without explaining it, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.