Question 1
4 marksSource B: From an economic intelligence report, 'Comparison of the First Five Year Plans of Communist China and the USSR', written by the Office of Research and Reports of the US Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in June 1959. It was a confidential report for US government officials and was based largely on Chinese official statistics.
Over-all output in China in the period 1952-57 grew at an average annual rate of about 7 percent -- as fast as, or possibly even faster than, output in the USSR in 1928-32. The growth of China's output was, however, much better balanced, for the reason that not only heavy industry but also light industry and agriculture expanded, whereas in the USSR agriculture declined seriously and light industry failed to expand. The Chinese economy accomplished this growth in output, which was comparable to growth in the Soviet First Five Year Plan, with a relatively smaller input of investment and with a great deal less disruption and suffering on the part of the population. The general standard of living even of urban workers declined in the USSR during this period, but in China the standard of living of both the agricultural and nonagricultural population rose.
Source C: From an article by Hughes H. Spurlock, an analyst in the Far East Analysis Branch of the US Department of Agriculture's Foreign Agricultural Service, published in March 1957 in Foreign Agriculture, the Department's monthly magazine. 'Communization' here means bringing farming under collective control. The USA had no diplomats or trade links in the People's Republic of China.
China's agriculture has barely managed to afford the minimum essentials for the world's largest and most rapidly expanding population. For centuries the Chinese peasant - and 75 percent of China's people live on the land - has been hard pressed to feed, clothe, and shelter himself and his family. So obviously before the peasants can help finance an ambitious industrialization program, agriculture itself must be made more productive, and in addition, a program of austerity enforced. ...
The government's approach to agricultural problems reflects three broad objectives: First, to guarantee political control of the countryside; second, to push ahead vigorously with the communization process; and, third, to increase production and hold consumption to the minimum.
Interpretation 1: From Rising from Poverty by Crispin Marchmont (fictional), published in 1983.
China's peasants did not carry the whole cost of the First Five-Year Plan. Land reform had freed them from rents that had often taken half the crop, and the agricultural tax took a smaller share of the harvest than the landlords had done. Much of the money for industry came from the profits of state factories and trading companies. Farm output rose by about a quarter between 1952 and 1957, and most peasants ate better than they had in the hungry years before 1949. The burden was real, but it was far lighter than the one Stalin had placed on Soviet peasants, and it did not cause a famine.
Interpretation 2: From The Squeeze by Agnes Cullingford (fictional), published in 2007.
The First Five-Year Plan was paid for by keeping consumption down, and the peasants paid most. Almost nine-tenths of industrial investment went to heavy industry, and from 1953 the state took a large share of every harvest through compulsory grain purchases at low prices, while it sold manufactured goods to the villages at high ones. When too much grain was taken after the floods of 1954, many villages went hungry in the spring of 1955. Peasants, who made up more than four-fifths of the population, gained least: their incomes rose only slightly, and the gap between town and countryside grew wider. The regime's priority was steel and machines, not the peasants who paid for them.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how heavy a burden the first Five-Year Plan placed on China's peasants. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 argues that the peasants 'did not carry the whole cost' of the plan and that their burden was 'far lighter than the one Stalin had placed on Soviet peasants'. This fits Source B, in which the CIA's comparison says that China's growth was 'much better balanced' than the Soviet Union's, came with 'a great deal less disruption and suffering', and that the standard of living of both 'the agricultural and nonagricultural population rose'.
Interpretation 2 argues that the plan 'was paid for by keeping consumption down, and the peasants paid most', through 'compulsory grain purchases at low prices'. This fits Source C, in which the US Department of Agriculture analyst says that before the peasants could 'help finance an ambitious industrialization program' a 'program of austerity' had to be 'enforced', and that the government aimed to 'hold consumption to the minimum'. A historian who compared China with Stalin's Russia would see a light burden; one who looked at how the plan was paid for would see a heavy one.
Explanation
Top answers give one clear reason, such as the use of different sources or a different yardstick, and support it by matching details: Source B's comparison with the Soviet Union and Interpretation 1's comparison with Stalin; Source C's 'program of austerity' and Interpretation 2's view that the peasants paid most. Answers that only say the historians 'used different sources', or that repeat the two views, stay in Level 1. Reasons based on the dates of publication are not valid.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B gives some support to Interpretation 1: the CIA's 1959 comparison says that China's growth was 'much better balanced' than the Soviet Union's, that 'not only heavy industry but also light industry and agriculture expanded', that it came with 'a great deal less disruption and suffering on the part of the population', and that 'the standard of living of both the agricultural and nonagricultural population rose'; this matches Interpretation 1's view that farm output 'rose by about a quarter', that 'most peasants ate better' and that the burden was 'far lighter than the one Stalin had placed on Soviet peasants'. Source C gives some support to Interpretation 2: the US Department of Agriculture analyst says that before the peasants could 'help finance an ambitious industrialization program' a 'program of austerity' had to be 'enforced', and that the government aimed to 'guarantee political control of the countryside' and to 'hold consumption to the minimum'; this matches Interpretation 2's view that the plan 'was paid for by keeping consumption down, and the peasants paid most', through 'compulsory grain purchases at low prices'. A student may note that Source B measures China against the Soviet First Five-Year Plan, a very low standard, while Source C looks at how the peasants were expected to pay for industrialisation. The interpretations may also differ because of the yardstick used: Interpretation 1 compares the peasants' position with the years before 1949 and with Stalin's Russia, while Interpretation 2 compares it with the towns and with what was taken from the villages; or because of a different focus: Interpretation 1 on output, food and rents, Interpretation 2 on grain purchases, prices and the hunger of spring 1955. Level 2 needs one reason explained and supported with details from the interpretations and, if used, matched details from the sources. Answers that only say 'Interpretation 2 used Source C' without matching details, or that repeat the difference of view, stay in Level 1. Do not credit reasons based only on the dates of publication or an assertion that a historian is biased.