'The Nicene Creed is the best summary of what Catholics believe.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Catholics would agree that the Nicene Creed is the best summary of their faith. It is professed at Mass every Sunday, so it is the summary Catholics know best, and it carries great authority because it comes from the first two ecumenical councils, Nicaea in 325 and Constantinople in 381 (CCC 195). It sets out the most important beliefs in order: God the Father as creator, the Son who is 'consubstantial with the Father' and who became man, died, rose and ascended, the Holy Spirit, the Church, baptism and the resurrection of the dead. Its words were chosen carefully to rule out errors such as the teaching of Arius, so it is precise as well as wide-ranging. It is also shared with Orthodox and many Protestant Christians, so it summarises the faith that unites Christians.
However, other Catholics would argue that it is not the best summary. The Catechism itself follows the Apostles' Creed, which it calls 'the oldest Roman catechism' (CCC 196), because it is simpler and is the ancient baptismal creed of the Church of Rome. The Nicene Creed also leaves out much that is central to Catholic life: it does not mention the Eucharist, which the Catechism calls 'the source and summit of the Christian life' (CCC 1324), the other sacraments, Mary's wider role or any moral teaching. Jesus summed up the law as loving God and loving your neighbour (Matthew 22:37-40), and some Catholics think this is a better summary, because faith must be lived and not only professed. The Catechism of the Catholic Church gives a much fuller summary, and even the Creed is not fully agreed, since the Orthodox reject the filioque.
In conclusion, I think the Nicene Creed is the best summary of what Catholics believe about God, because of its authority and the careful way it sets out the Trinity and the work of Christ. However, it is not a complete summary of Catholic faith, because belief is only part of being Catholic: the sacraments and the command to love must be added. So I agree with the statement only for the beliefs about God, not for Catholic life as a whole.
Explanation
Top answers judge whether the Creed is the 'best' summary by comparing it with real alternatives, such as the Apostles' Creed, the Catechism or Jesus' two great commandments. Use accurate Catholic teaching, for example the authority of the councils of Nicaea and Constantinople, and apply it to the word 'best'. A common weakness is to describe what the Creed says without evaluating whether anything important is missing.