'For Catholics, the whole world is sacramental.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are strong reasons to agree. Catholic teaching holds that God's presence can be experienced through the physical world: the Catechism says that 'God speaks to man through the visible creation' (CCC 1147), and St Paul writes that God's invisible qualities are 'clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made' (Romans 1:20). Pope Francis went further, saying there is a mystical meaning 'in a leaf, in a mountain trail, in a dewdrop, in a poor person's face' (Laudato Si' 233). The Incarnation shows that God is willing to work through matter, since 'the Word was made flesh' (John 1:14). The Second Vatican Council even taught that there is hardly any proper use of material things that cannot be directed towards the praise of God (Sacrosanctum Concilium 61). In this sense, every part of the world can become a meeting place with God.
However, the word 'sacramental' needs care. In the strict sense the Catholic Church recognises only seven sacraments, which are 'efficacious signs of grace, instituted by Christ' (CCC 1131): they do not just remind people of God but actually give his life. A sunset may lead someone to praise God, but it does not wash away sin as baptism does, and Christ is not present in a mountain in the way he is present in the Eucharist, 'truly, really, and substantially' (CCC 1374). Catholic teaching also insists that God is distinct from creation, so calling everything sacramental could lead to pantheism. Sin and suffering have damaged the world, so creation can hide God as well as reveal him. Many Protestants would add that God is known mainly through Scripture rather than nature.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement if 'sacramental' means that the whole world can point to God and become a place of encounter with him, which is what the Church means by the sacramental nature of reality. However, I would not agree that the whole world is a sacrament, because the seven sacraments give grace in a unique way that nature does not. The best Catholic answer is that the world is sacramental because the sacraments themselves show what all created things are for.
Explanation
This is a demanding statement, and the best answers distinguish between the sacramental nature of reality and the seven sacraments in the strict sense. Use precise sources, such as CCC 1147 or Laudato Si' 233 for and CCC 1131 against, and weigh them. A justified conclusion explains in what sense the statement is true or false.