'Praying for the person who has died is the most important part of a Catholic funeral.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Catholics would agree with this statement. When a Christian dies, the Church 'intercedes on behalf of the deceased' (Order of Christian Funerals 4) and 'commends the dead to God's merciful love and pleads for the forgiveness of their sins' (OCF 6). Catholics believe that those who die in God's friendship but are not yet fully purified pass through purgatory, and that the prayers of the living help them. The Catechism says that from the beginning the Church has offered prayers for the dead, 'above all the Eucharistic sacrifice' (CCC 1032), following the teaching that it is 'a holy and wholesome thought to pray for the dead' (2 Maccabees 12:46). The person who has died can no longer do anything for themselves, so praying for them is the last and greatest act of love the community can offer. It is also what makes a Catholic funeral distinctive, and the final commendation, the Church's 'commendation to God' of the deceased (CCC 1690), is often the most moving moment of the rite.
However, there are strong reasons to disagree. The Order of Christian Funerals says that Christians celebrate the funeral rites first of all 'to offer worship, praise, and thanksgiving to God' for the gift of a life (OCF 5), so the funeral is centred on God rather than on any one activity. The Catechism teaches that the Christian meaning of death is revealed in the light of the death and resurrection of Christ (CCC 1681), and the Second Vatican Council asked that funeral rites express 'the paschal character of Christian death' (Sacrosanctum Concilium 81), so proclaiming the resurrection could be seen as the heart of the rite. The funeral also 'brings hope and consolation to the living' (OCF 7), and for grieving families this comfort is vital. Many Protestant Christians do not pray for the dead at all, believing that 'it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment' (Hebrews 9:27), so for them thanksgiving and comfort are the most important parts of a funeral.
In conclusion, I partly agree. Prayer for the person who has died is essential to a Catholic funeral and is what most clearly separates it from many other Christian funerals. But it is not the most important part on its own, because it takes place within the worship of God in the funeral Mass, whose heart is Christ's death and resurrection. It is the hope of the resurrection that makes prayer for the dead meaningful, so the celebration of the paschal mystery is the deeper centre of the rite.
Explanation
Strong answers explain the Catholic basis for praying for the dead (purgatory, the communion of saints, OCF 6) and weigh it against the other purposes the Church gives a funeral, such as worship of God, proclaiming the resurrection and comforting the mourners. Include a Protestant view to show a difference within Christianity. A justified conclusion considers how these purposes relate to each other rather than simply picking one.