'The SVP's work of befriending people is more important than the practical help it gives.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people would agree with this statement. Loneliness and isolation are a serious form of poverty, and friendship is something that only people, not systems, can give. The SVP itself puts long-term befriending through home visits at the heart of its work, and members visit people in their homes, in hospital, in care homes and in prison, treating each person as an equal rather than as a problem to be solved. Frederic Ozanam believed that he met Christ in the poor people he visited, and Jesus himself spent time with people, as when he ate with Zacchaeus (Luke 19:1-10). St Teresa of Calcutta is often quoted as saying that being unwanted and unloved is a terrible kind of poverty, and Pope Francis wrote that real love for the poor begins with loving attention to the person, not just programmes of help. Practical help can also come from the state or other charities, but friendship is the SVP's distinctive gift.
However, there are strong reasons to disagree. If a family has no food, heating or bed, friendship alone does not meet their needs. The Letter of James warns that it is useless to wish someone well without giving them what the body needs (James 2:15-16), and in the parable of the Sheep and the Goats people are judged on whether they fed the hungry and clothed the naked (Matthew 25:35-36). The corporal works of mercy in the Catechism are practical actions (CCC 2447), and Gaudium et Spes 26 teaches that everyone has a right to the food, clothing and shelter needed for a truly human life. Some people may want practical help without a relationship, and respecting their wishes is part of respecting their dignity. Many other Christian groups, such as the Salvation Army and church food banks, focus strongly on practical relief.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement, because the SVP's own practice shows that the two belong together. Befriending gives the SVP its special character and makes its practical help respectful rather than cold, while practical help shows that the friendship is real. When someone's basic needs are urgent, practical help must come first, but over time it is friendship that helps people regain hope, so neither is complete without the other.
Explanation
Top answers explain what befriending and practical help each achieve, using sources such as Matthew 25, James 2 and CCC 2447, and recognise that the SVP deliberately combines them. A judgement that explains when one matters more than the other shows Level 4 evaluation. Avoid describing the SVP's work without weighing the two kinds of help.