'Catholics and other Christians should be allowed to share Holy Communion together.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are strong arguments for allowing Catholics and other Christians to share Communion. Jesus prayed for his followers 'that they all may be one' (John 17:21), and St Paul teaches that 'we being many are one bread, and one body' (1 Corinthians 10:17). The Catholic Church itself recognises that all baptised Christians are in some, though imperfect, communion with it (CCC 1271). Many Protestant churches, such as the Methodist Church and the Church of England, already welcome baptised Christians of any denomination to receive Communion. Being refused can be hurtful, especially for families in which husband and wife belong to different churches. Some Christians argue that sharing Communion would help to heal divisions, and the Catholic Church already allows other Christians to receive in cases of grave necessity if they share the Catholic faith in the sacrament (CCC 1401).
However, the Catholic Church teaches that Communion should express a unity that already exists, not one that is only hoped for. When a person receives the host and says 'Amen', they are declaring their belief that it is truly the body of Christ. Many Protestants do not believe this, so receiving together would hide real differences rather than heal them. The Catechism explains that communities that come from the Reformation 'have not preserved the proper reality of the Eucharistic mystery in its fullness', especially because they lack the sacrament of holy orders, and so intercommunion with them is not possible (CCC 1400). St Paul warns against receiving without 'discerning the Lord's body' (1 Corinthians 11:29). The Catholic bishops of Britain and Ireland explained this in One Bread One Body (1998), and the Orthodox Churches take a similar view.
In conclusion, I understand why many Christians want to share Communion, and the pain of division is real. However, I think the Catholic position is consistent: if the Eucharist is truly Christ's body, sharing it must be a sign of full agreement in faith. The better way to unity is through prayer, dialogue and shared service, so that one day Christians can share Communion honestly.
Explanation
Strong answers explain why the Catholic Church links Communion to full unity of faith and holy orders (CCC 1400), and give fair weight to the experience and arguments of other denominations. Precise references, such as John 17:21 and CCC 1401, strengthen both sides. Avoid presenting either side as unkind or unreasonable; the evaluation should rest on the reasons given.