'Catholic agencies should spend their money on emergencies rather than on long-term development.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people would agree with this statement. When a disaster strikes, lives are at risk immediately and people cannot wait for long-term plans. The Good Samaritan did not set up a programme to make the road safer; he stopped and met the urgent needs of the man in front of him (Luke 10:25-37). Jesus identified himself with the hungry and the thirsty (Matthew 25:35), and the corporal works of mercy in the Catechism, such as feeding the hungry and sheltering the homeless, are about urgent needs (CCC 2447). Catholic agencies are especially well placed to help in emergencies because they work through local churches and the Caritas network, which are already on the ground. Many people also give in response to emergency appeals and expect their money to be used for that, while long-term projects can be slow and their results harder to see.
However, there are strong reasons to disagree. Long-term development tackles the causes of poverty, so it can prevent future emergencies: a community with clean water, drought-resistant crops and flood defences is far less likely to need emergency help. Pope Paul VI taught in Populorum Progressio that development is 'the new name for peace', and Catholic teaching stresses integral human development, which means helping people to flourish in every way. Helping people to support themselves also respects their dignity and avoids dependency, which fits the principle of subsidiarity. Trocaire was founded to treat help for the poor as a matter of justice, not just charity, and justice means changing unfair situations, not only relieving suffering. Emergencies attract media attention and government funds, while chronic poverty is easily forgotten, so Catholic agencies have a special role in long-term work. Other Christian agencies, such as Christian Aid and Tearfund, also combine both kinds of work.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Emergencies must always be answered, because Christians cannot walk past people in immediate danger. But if agencies spent their money only on emergencies, they would be dealing with the same crises again and again without ever tackling their causes. The best approach, which CAFOD and Trocaire follow, is to respond generously to emergencies while putting long-term development at the heart of their work.
Explanation
The best answers weigh the urgency of saving lives against the value of preventing future suffering, using Catholic teaching such as the works of mercy, Populorum Progressio or the principle of subsidiarity. They also recognise that agencies like CAFOD do both and reach a reasoned judgement about the balance. Simply listing what CAFOD does, without evaluating the statement, keeps an answer in the lower levels.