'The Rosary is more about Mary than about Jesus.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people would agree with this statement. The Rosary is often called a Marian prayer, and the Church's Directory on Popular Piety calls it the 'Psalter of the Blessed Virgin Mary' (197). Most of its words are Hail Marys: each decade has one Our Father but ten Hail Marys, and it usually ends with the Hail, Holy Queen. Two of the Glorious Mysteries, the Assumption and the Coronation of Mary, are about Mary herself, and the Rosary is closely linked with Marian shrines: at Fatima in 1917 Mary was reported to call herself 'the Lady of the Rosary'. Many Protestant Christians therefore see the Rosary as giving Mary an honour that belongs to God alone, since Christ is the 'one mediator between God and men' (1 Timothy 2:5).
However, the Catholic Church teaches the opposite. Pope John Paul II wrote that the Rosary, 'though clearly Marian in character, is at heart a Christocentric prayer' (Rosarium Virginis Mariae 1). Almost all of its twenty mysteries are events in the life of Jesus, from the Annunciation to his resurrection and ascension, and the Catechism says that Christian prayer meditates on the mysteries of Christ 'as in lectio divina or the rosary' (CCC 2708). The name of Jesus is the 'centre of gravity' of the Hail Mary (RVM 33), and each decade begins with the Our Father, the prayer Jesus taught, and ends with the Glory Be to the Trinity. John Paul II added the Luminous Mysteries in 2002 precisely to make the Rosary more fully a summary of the Gospel. For Catholics, Mary is the guide, not the goal: at Cana she told the servants, 'Whatsoever he saith unto you, do it' (John 2:5), and in the Rosary she leads people to her Son. The Catechism adds that devotion to Mary 'differs essentially' from the adoration given to God (CCC 971).
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Mary is very present in the words of the Rosary, so it is understandable that people think it is mainly about her. But the content of the prayer - the mysteries on which Catholics meditate - is overwhelmingly about Jesus, and Mary's role is to help people contemplate him. The Rosary is best described as a prayer with Mary about Jesus, rather than a prayer that is more about Mary than about him.
Explanation
The best answers distinguish between the words of the Rosary (mostly Hail Marys) and its content (mostly mysteries of Christ), which allows a well-justified conclusion. Use Catholic sources such as Rosarium Virginis Mariae and CCC 2708, and represent Protestant objections fairly. Avoid simply describing how to pray the Rosary without evaluating the claim.