'Places of pilgrimage have become too commercial to be truly holy.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people would agree. At famous shrines such as Lourdes, the streets near the sanctuary are lined with hotels and shops selling souvenirs, including plastic bottles for the water and statues of Mary, and pilgrimages can be expensive. Critics argue that this turns a holy place into a tourist attraction where money matters more than prayer. Jesus drove the traders out of the Temple, saying 'make not my Father's house an house of merchandise' (John 2:16), which suggests that God is displeased when worship is mixed with profit. At the Reformation, Protestant leaders strongly criticised the trade in relics and indulgences linked with pilgrimage, and many Protestants today still see shrines as places where faith and commerce have become confused. Crowds and noise can also make it hard to pray.
However, many Catholics would disagree. They believe a place is holy because of what God has done there and because of the prayer offered there, not because of the shops nearby: at the burning bush God told Moses, 'the place whereon thou standest is holy ground' (Exodus 3:5). At Lourdes the sanctuary itself is separate from the shops, entry is free and the water from the spring is freely available. Souvenirs such as rosaries and medals can help pilgrims to keep praying when they return home, and the shops and hotels provide work for local people and food and shelter for pilgrims. Above all, holiness can be seen in what happens there: confessions, Masses, processions and the volunteers who care for sick and disabled pilgrims. The Catechism teaches that shrines are special places for prayer and that pilgrimages are occasions for renewal in prayer (CCC 2691), and millions of pilgrims still experience this. Even Jesus did not abandon the Temple; he cleansed it and continued to worship there.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Commercialism is a real danger and can distract pilgrims, so Catholics need to guard against it, as Jesus did in the Temple. But a place does not stop being holy because of shops outside it: its holiness comes from God and from the faith, prayer and love of the people who go there. The way each pilgrim behaves matters more than the souvenir stalls.
Explanation
Good answers use a real place of pilgrimage as evidence and weigh the problem of commercialism against what makes a place holy in Catholic belief. Include a Protestant perspective and apply biblical teaching such as John 2:16 or Exodus 3:5 to the statement. A justified conclusion should explain where holiness comes from, rather than just repeating that shrines are busy.