'The Anointing of the Sick is more about spiritual healing than physical healing.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There is good evidence that the anointing is mainly about spiritual healing. The Catechism says that the first grace of the sacrament is 'strengthening, peace and courage' to overcome the difficulties of serious illness (CCC 1520), which are spiritual gifts. The Letter of James promises that 'if he have committed sins, they shall be forgiven him' (James 5:15), so the sacrament heals the soul through forgiveness. It also unites the sick person with the suffering of Christ, so that their suffering 'acquires a new meaning' (CCC 1521), and it prepares those near death for the final journey. Physical healing is promised only 'if such is God's will' (CCC 1520), and in practice most people who are anointed are not cured, yet Catholics still believe the sacrament has worked.
On the other hand, the sacrament was always meant to include the body. James says that 'the prayer of faith shall save the sick, and the Lord shall raise him up' (James 5:15), and the Gospels record that the apostles 'anointed with oil many that were sick, and healed them' (Mark 6:13). The Catechism teaches that Jesus came 'to heal the whole man, soul and body' (CCC 1503), and it explicitly lists healing of the body among the effects of the anointing. Catholics believe a person is a unity of body and soul, so it may be a mistake to separate the two kinds of healing; the peace and courage the sacrament gives can help a patient's recovery. The Orthodox Church prays in Holy Unction for healing of both soul and body, and many Pentecostal Christians pray for physical healing with the laying on of hands.
In conclusion, I agree that the sacrament is more about spiritual healing, because the spiritual graces are always given while physical healing depends on God's will. However, the statement should not be taken to mean that the body does not matter. The anointing heals the whole person, and the spiritual healing it always brings is what makes it possible to face illness, recovery or death with faith.
Explanation
Strong answers use CCC 1520, which mentions both kinds of healing, and weigh which is central, supported by James 5 and Mark 6:13. Recognising that body and soul are a unity in Catholic teaching is a good way to reach a nuanced conclusion. Avoid claiming either that the sacrament never brings physical healing or that it always does.