'Jesus' humanity is more important for Catholics than his divinity.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some Catholics might argue that Jesus' humanity is more important for them in daily life. Because Jesus was truly human, he understands what they go through: Hebrews 4:15 says he was 'in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin'. His human life gives Catholics an example they can follow; the Catechism calls him 'our model of holiness' (CCC 459). It was as a human being that he suffered and died on the cross, and much Catholic devotion focuses on his humanity, such as the crucifix, the Stations of the Cross and the Sacred Heart, which shows that he loved us 'with a human heart' (CCC 478). Jesus also taught that he is met in the hungry and the stranger (Matthew 25:40), so serving other humans is a way of serving him.
However, most Catholics would reject the statement. Many good people have lived and died for others, but only Jesus is God, so his divinity is what makes him unique. Only God can forgive sins (Mark 2:7), and if Jesus were only a man his death could not reconcile the world to God; this is why the Council of Nicaea defended his full divinity against Arius. Catholics worship Jesus, for example in Eucharistic adoration, which would be idolatry if he were not God, and the Catechism teaches that the resurrection confirms his divinity (CCC 653). Above all, the Church teaches that Jesus is not part God and part man (CCC 464): the Council of Chalcedon said his two natures exist 'without division or separation' (CCC 467), so it makes no sense to rank one above the other. The Orthodox tradition adds that God became human so that humans might share in God's life (CCC 460), which depends on both natures together.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Jesus' humanity is the way Catholics come close to him, but it matters precisely because it is the humanity of God. If either nature is lost, the Incarnation and salvation are lost too, so for Catholics his humanity and divinity are equally important and cannot be separated.
Explanation
Top answers weigh the practical importance of Jesus' humanity for prayer and moral life against the importance of his divinity for salvation, using Catholic sources such as CCC 464 and the Council of Chalcedon. A strong conclusion may argue that the two natures cannot be ranked, provided this follows from the arguments. Avoid describing Jesus as part God and part man.