'The creation accounts in Genesis can be true without being literally true.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Most Catholics would agree with this statement. The Second Vatican Council taught that scripture teaches 'without error that truth which God wanted put into sacred writings for the sake of salvation' (Dei Verbum 11): in other words, the Bible's purpose is religious truth, not science. Readers must also pay attention to 'literary forms' (Dei Verbum 12), and the Catechism says the six days are presented 'symbolically' (CCC 337). Genesis 1 and 2 even give the events of creation in different orders, which suggests they were never meant as literal history. Yet they teach deep truths: that God created everything out of nothing, that creation is good and that humans are made in God's image. The Catholic priest Georges LemaƮtre helped to develop the Big Bang theory, and St John Paul II said in 1996 that evolution was more than a hypothesis, so for Catholics the truth of Genesis does not depend on its details being scientific.
However, some Christians would disagree. Many evangelical Protestants believe the Bible is the inerrant word of God, so if Genesis says the world was made in six days, it was. They point out that Jesus spoke of God making humans 'male and female' at the beginning (Matthew 19:4) and that St Paul treats Adam as a real person (Romans 5:12), and they worry that if Genesis is not literal, other events such as the resurrection may also be explained away. The Catholic Church itself does not treat everything in Genesis as symbol: it teaches that the story of the Fall, although it uses figurative language, affirms a real event at the beginning of human history (CCC 390). Atheists would disagree from the other side, arguing that if the accounts are not literally true then they are simply myths.
In conclusion, I agree with the statement. A text can express truth through poetry or story, just as Jesus' parables do, and the differences between Genesis 1 and 2 show that their authors were not writing science. However, 'not literally true' must not mean 'not true at all': Catholics hold that the central claims, that God created freely and that humans have a unique dignity, are true in the most important sense.
Explanation
Top answers explain what Catholics mean by religious truth, using Dei Verbum 11-12 or CCC 337, and weigh this against the literalist view held by some other Christians. Including the Catholic nuance that some elements, such as the reality of God's creation and of the Fall, are still affirmed shows a strong grasp of the issue. Avoid suggesting that all Christians read Genesis in the same way.