'Catholic social teaching is too idealistic to make a real difference in the world today.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some people, including some Catholics, would agree with this statement. Catholic social teaching describes an ideal world in which the goods of the earth are shared by everyone and every person has food, shelter, education and work, as Gaudium et Spes 26 says. Yet more than 130 years after Rerum Novarum, great poverty and inequality remain. Governments and businesses rarely follow papal encyclicals, and many Catholics have never read them, which is why Catholic social teaching is sometimes called the Church's 'best-kept secret'. The documents are long and written in difficult language, so they can seem far removed from ordinary people's lives. Critics also say that scandals within the Church have weakened its voice when it tells the world how to behave, and many Protestant Christians do not accept the authority of papal teaching at all.
However, there is strong evidence that Catholic social teaching does make a real difference. Rerum Novarum defended workers' right to a just wage and to form trade unions at a time when this was controversial, and it influenced workers' movements and labour laws in many countries. The principle of subsidiarity was written into European Union law in 1992. Pope John Paul II called for the debts of poor countries to be reduced or cancelled for the year 2000, and the Jubilee 2000 campaign, backed by agencies such as CAFOD, helped to persuade rich countries to cancel large debts owed by some of the poorest nations. Catholic social teaching also inspires the daily work of CAFOD, Trocaire and the SVP. Pope Leo XIV chose his name because of Rerum Novarum, saying the Church's social teaching must respond to a new industrial revolution, including artificial intelligence, which shows it is still being applied to new problems. Many Catholics would add that ideals are meant to challenge us: Jesus taught 'Be ye therefore perfect' (Matthew 5:48), which is idealistic, yet it has changed countless lives.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Catholic social teaching is idealistic in the sense that its goals have not been fully reached, but an ideal is what gives action its direction. Its history shows that it has helped to change laws, inspired campaigns and motivated many ordinary Catholics to serve others, so it clearly makes a real difference, even if the world still falls short of it.
Explanation
The best answers test the claim against evidence, such as the influence of Rerum Novarum, the Jubilee 2000 debt campaign or the work of CAFOD, rather than only describing what Catholic social teaching says. Recognising why some see it as idealistic and still reaching a reasoned judgement lifts an answer to the top level. Avoid vague claims with no named teaching, document or example.