'Catholic schools are the most effective way for the Church to carry out its mission in Britain.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Catholic teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Catholics would agree with this statement. Catholic schools in England and Wales reach very large numbers of young people every day, far more than any parish youth group. Pupils learn about the faith in RE, pray together, celebrate Mass, prepare for the sacraments and can talk to a chaplain. Many pupils come from families who rarely go to church, or are not Catholic at all, so schools are one of the main places where the new evangelisation can happen. Catholic schools also show the faith in action through CAFOD campaigns, Mini Vinnies and Youth SVP groups, and the Second Vatican Council's Gravissimum Educationis stressed how important Catholic education is for the Church's mission. This is why the Church in England and Wales has worked so hard to build and run schools since the nineteenth century.
However, there are strong arguments against the statement. Many young people stop practising their faith soon after they leave school, which suggests schools cannot create lasting faith on their own. The Church teaches that parents are the first teachers of their children in the ways of faith, so the family matters even more than the school. The Eucharist is the source and summit of the Christian life (CCC 1324), so the parish, where Catholics of every age worship together week by week, is the heart of mission. Mission is also for adults and for the whole of society: lay Catholics are called to witness at work and in public life, and Pope Francis asks the Church to go out to the poor and those on the margins, whom schools do not reach. Pope Paul VI wrote that people today listen more willingly to witnesses than to teachers (Evangelii Nuntiandi 41), so the example of ordinary Catholics may be more powerful than lessons. Some evangelical and Pentecostal churches in Britain have grown without running schools at all, through lively worship and personal invitation.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Catholic schools are an extremely important part of the Church's mission, because they reach so many young people. But they are most effective when family and parish support what pupils learn, and they cannot reach adults or those on the margins. The most effective mission is the shared witness of families, parishes and schools together, carried into everyday life.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh the real strengths of Catholic schools against other places of mission, such as the family, the parish and the witness of lay Catholics, using sources like Evangelii Nuntiandi 41 or CCC 1324. Considering the word 'most' carefully and reaching a justified judgement is what lifts an answer to Level 4. Avoid simply describing what happens in a Catholic school without evaluating its effectiveness.