Question 1
1 markA student notices that there are more barnacles on rocks near the low tide mark than on rocks higher up the shore. Barnacles are small animals that feed by filtering food from sea water.
Which is a hypothesis that the student could test?
Choose your answer.
- A Barnacle numbers decrease with height up the shore, because higher rocks are covered by sea water for less time.
- B Barnacles prefer rocks near the low tide mark, because they like to be as close to the sea as possible.
- C How does the number of barnacles on the rocks change with height above the low tide mark?
- D The seashore is an interesting habitat, so the student should count the barnacles on every rock.
Model answer
A
Explanation
A hypothesis is a testable idea, based on scientific knowledge, about how one variable affects another. A good hypothesis names the variables to measure and gives a scientific reason, so the results can support it or not. A question such as option C is a starting point for an investigation, but it makes no prediction.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A / Barnacle numbers decrease with height up the shore, because higher rocks are covered by sea water for less time.
The only correct answer is A: it predicts a relationship between two variables that can be measured (height up the shore and number of barnacles) and gives a reason based on scientific knowledge (barnacles can feed only when they are covered by sea water). B is not correct because 'they like to be close to the sea' is not a scientific explanation, so the reason cannot be tested; C is not correct because it is a question for an investigation, not a hypothesis: it makes no prediction and gives no explanation; D is not correct because it is an opinion about the habitat and a suggestion for the method, not a testable prediction. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.