'Wesak is the most important festival for Buddhists in Britain today.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Buddhists in Britain would agree that Wesak is the most important festival. For Theravada Buddhists it remembers the Buddha's birth, enlightenment and passing away (parinibbana), which they believe all happened on the full moon of Vesakha. These events are the foundation of Buddhism: without the Buddha's enlightenment there would be no Dhamma to follow and no Sangha. Wesak is also celebrated by almost every Buddhist tradition in some form, so in a country where Buddhists are a small and varied minority it can bring together people of Sri Lankan, Thai, Chinese and British backgrounds. It is also a day of serious practice, when many keep the eight precepts, meditate and make merit. Because the Buddha said in the Mahaparinibbana Sutta that he is best honoured by people who follow his teaching, a festival given to practice seems a fitting way to put him at the centre of Buddhist life.
However, others would disagree. In many East Asian Mahayana traditions the spring festival only celebrates the Buddha's birth, while his enlightenment and parinirvana have their own days, so Wesak is one important festival among several. Some Buddhists would argue that Parinirvana Day has a deeper message, because reflecting on the Buddha's death teaches impermanence. In practice, other festivals can be the biggest events for particular groups in Britain: Kathina, when lay people offer robes after the rains retreat, draws large numbers to monasteries such as Amaravati, and Triratna Buddhists also celebrate Sangha Day and Dharma Day. Many Buddhists would also say that no festival is really 'most important', because festivals are only aids; the Buddha taught that enlightenment comes from daily ethics and meditation, and in Britain, where festivals are not public holidays, regular practice and retreats may matter more than any single day.
In conclusion, I think Wesak is the most important festival for many Buddhists in Britain, especially Theravada Buddhists, because it celebrates the enlightenment that makes Buddhism possible and unites Buddhists of different backgrounds. However, it is not the most important for all Buddhists, since traditions differ in what they celebrate, and most Buddhists would agree that the way of life a festival inspires matters more than the festival itself.
Explanation
The best answers compare Wesak with named alternatives, such as Parinirvana Day or Kathina, and show how Theravada and Mahayana Buddhists differ, rather than just describing Wesak. The statement is about Britain today, so points about Buddhists being a small minority or festivals not being public holidays are relevant. Make sure the conclusion weighs the arguments and is not just a repeat of one side.