'For Buddhists, keeping the five precepts is more important than meditating.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Buddhists would agree that keeping the five precepts is more important than meditating. Ethics (sila) is the foundation of the Threefold Way: without ethical conduct the mind is troubled by guilt and restlessness, and meditation cannot develop. In the Anguttara Nikaya (10.1) the Buddha explains that skilful virtue leads to freedom from remorse, which leads step by step to joy, calm, concentration and insight. The Dhammapada's summary of the teaching of all Buddhas begins 'Not to commit any sin' (verse 183). The precepts also protect other people and animals, whereas meditation might seem to benefit mainly the meditator. Every Buddhist can keep the precepts, but not everyone has the time or ability to meditate for long; in many Theravada communities lay practice has centred on keeping the precepts, generosity and puja rather than intensive meditation.
However, others would argue that meditation is more important, or at least just as important. The Buddha reached enlightenment through meditation under the Bodhi tree, not by keeping rules alone, and the precepts cannot by themselves remove ignorance; only the wisdom that grows from meditation, especially insight (vipassana), can do that. Dhammapada 372 teaches that 'Without knowledge there is no meditation, without meditation there is no knowledge'. Meditation also helps Buddhists to keep the precepts, because mindfulness lets them notice anger or craving before they act on it. In Zen Buddhism zazen is at the very centre of practice. Many Buddhists would say the comparison is mistaken, because ethics, meditation and wisdom form one path and each supports the others. Pure Land Buddhists might add that faith in Amitabha matters more than either.
In conclusion, I think the precepts are more important in the sense that they come first: a Buddhist who meditates but harms others is not following the Buddha's path. However, keeping the precepts is not enough on its own to reach enlightenment, and meditation makes it easier to keep them, so the two are best seen as partners, with the precepts as the foundation and meditation as what builds on it.
Explanation
The best answers use the Threefold Way to show how ethics and meditation are related, and support each side with teaching such as Anguttara Nikaya 10.1 or Dhammapada 372. Including different traditions, such as Theravada lay practice, Zen and Pure Land, shows diversity. A conclusion that explains the relationship between the two is stronger than one that simply picks a side.