'Understanding the cause of suffering is more important than understanding suffering itself.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are good reasons to agree that understanding the cause of suffering is more important than understanding suffering itself. Most people already know that they suffer: they experience illness, disappointment and loss. What they do not understand is why. The Second Noble Truth teaches that the cause is craving (tanha), linked to the Three Poisons of greed, hatred and ignorance, and this is the knowledge that makes it possible to do something about suffering. A doctor who recognised an illness but never discovered its cause could not cure it. In his first sermon the Buddha said that the origin of suffering is 'to be abandoned', so understanding the cause tells Buddhists exactly what to work on. It also shows that suffering is not random or a punishment, but has a cause that can be changed, which gives hope. The Fire Sermon likewise focuses on the fires that cause suffering rather than on describing suffering itself.
However, others argue that understanding suffering comes first and matters just as much. No one looks for a cause until they have recognised the problem: Siddhartha's search began when the Four Sights showed him old age, sickness and death. The Buddha began his first sermon with the truth of suffering and said that it is 'to be fully understood', and understanding it fully is not simple. Many people see obvious pain but not sankhara-dukkha, the unsatisfactoriness of all conditioned existence, so they keep looking for lasting happiness in things that cannot provide it. Understanding suffering deeply also leads to compassion (karuna) for all beings. Many Buddhists would say the truths cannot be ranked, because the cause only makes sense in relation to suffering, and both lead on to the Third and Fourth Truths, which some see as the most important because they show the goal and the path. Mahayana texts such as the Heart Sutra even teach that all four truths are empty of fixed existence, so ranking them misses the point.
In conclusion, I think understanding the cause is slightly more important, because it turns awareness of suffering into something a person can act on. However, this is only true for someone who has already understood suffering deeply; without that understanding, the cause would seem irrelevant. The two truths work together like a diagnosis and its explanation, so the cause is more useful for practice, but neither truth is complete without the other.
Explanation
The strongest answers explain both truths accurately, including what it means to understand dukkha fully (for example sankhara-dukkha), and then weigh them against each other using teaching from the first sermon. Pointing out that the Four Noble Truths depend on each other is a good different view, but it still needs reasons. Avoid describing all Four Noble Truths in turn without ever comparing the first two.