'Sunyata is the most important Mahayana teaching about the human personality.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
There are strong reasons to see sunyata as the most important Mahayana teaching about the human personality. It is the central idea of the Perfection of Wisdom sutras and of Nagarjuna's Madhyamaka school, which shaped Mahayana thought for centuries. The Heart Sutra, chanted daily in temples across the Mahayana world, teaches that the five skandhas are empty, so a person has no fixed nature of their own. This deepens the earlier teaching of anatta: not only is there no self behind the aggregates, but the aggregates themselves exist only in dependence on other things. Realising this is the wisdom (prajna) that frees people from clinging. Nagarjuna even argued that change and liberation are possible only because things are empty, which suggests that the possibility of Buddhahood itself depends on sunyata.
On the other hand, many Mahayana Buddhists would put Buddha-nature first. In East Asian traditions such as Zen, the key insight is that every being is already Buddha by nature; Hakuin taught that all beings are Buddha as ice is water. This describes the human personality positively and gives people confidence to practise, whereas emptiness can be misunderstood as meaning that nothing matters. Others would say the possibility of attaining Buddhahood is most important, since it is the goal that gives the Bodhisattva path its purpose. Pure Land Buddhists are likely to say that understanding emptiness is less important than entrusting oneself to Amida Buddha, who makes Buddhahood possible for ordinary people. Many Mahayana teachers also describe wisdom and compassion as the two wings of a bird, so that emptiness without compassion would be incomplete.
In conclusion, I think sunyata is the most important teaching in a logical sense, because Buddha-nature and the possibility of Buddhahood both rely on the fact that people have no fixed nature and so can change. However, for many Mahayana Buddhists in practice, Buddha-nature is more important, because it is what inspires them to practise. The statement is therefore true of Mahayana philosophy, especially in the Madhyamaka and Tibetan traditions, but less true of the devotional and Zen traditions.
Explanation
Top-level answers compare sunyata with Buddha-nature and the possibility of Buddhahood, using sources such as the Heart Sutra, Nagarjuna or Hakuin, and recognise that different Mahayana traditions emphasise different teachings. Make sure you explain sunyata accurately as emptiness of independent existence. A justified conclusion might distinguish between logical priority and practical importance.