'Wisdom is the most important of the six perfections.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Buddhists, especially in the Mahayana tradition, would agree that wisdom (prajna) is the most important perfection. Shantideva begins the wisdom chapter of the Bodhicaryavatara by saying that the Buddha taught all the other perfections for the sake of wisdom (9.1), and Perfection of Wisdom texts compare the other five without wisdom to blind people with no guide. Wisdom is the direct remedy for ignorance, the root of suffering, because it sees the truth of emptiness (sunyata) and no-self; the Heart Sutra, one of the most chanted Mahayana texts, is entirely about it. In Mahayana teaching, generosity or patience only become 'perfections' when they are joined with this understanding. In the Theravada tradition too, it is wisdom (panna) that finally brings nibbana.
However, other Buddhists would argue differently. Mahayana Buddhism itself teaches that wisdom must be balanced by compassion, like the two wings of a bird; wisdom without compassion could become cold and detached, and the first perfections, especially generosity, express that compassion. Generosity is the first perfection, the foundation of the path, and the one most lay Buddhists practise every day. Shantideva gives great importance to other perfections as well: he says there is no evil like hatred and no practice like patience (6.2), and that awakening depends on energy (7.1). Morality is the basis of meditation, and meditation is needed for wisdom to grow, so many Buddhists would say that the six perfections depend on each other and none can be singled out. Pure Land Buddhists might also put faith in Amitabha before any of the perfections.
In conclusion, I think wisdom is the most important perfection in the sense that it gives the others their direction and turns them into true perfections, which is why Shantideva says they were all taught for its sake. However, wisdom cannot grow without the other perfections, and in Mahayana Buddhism it must always be joined with compassion, so it is best seen as the crown of the six rather than as something that can stand alone.
Explanation
Top answers support both sides with specific teaching, such as Bodhicaryavatara 9.1 for wisdom and the two wings of compassion and wisdom against, rather than listing the perfections. Weighing whether any perfection can be 'most important' when they depend on each other shows strong evaluation. Make sure your conclusion is justified by the arguments you have given.