'The main purpose of Buddhist death rituals is to help the dead person towards a good rebirth.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Buddhists would agree that helping the dead person is the main purpose of death rituals. Theravada Buddhists make merit on behalf of the dead by giving food and robes to the monks and pouring water into a bowl until it overflows, to show the merit flowing to them. The Tirokudda Kanda Sutta teaches that, while weeping does not help the dead, a gift given to the Sangha on their behalf does, and the Sigalovada Sutta makes offerings for departed relatives a duty of children. Tibetan Buddhists read the Bardo Thodol to the dead because they believe the consciousness passes through the bardo for up to 49 days and can be guided towards liberation or a good rebirth, and prayers continue throughout that time. In Japan, many people believe memorial services and Obon benefit their ancestors, following the Ullambana Sutra, in which Maudgalyayana's offerings free his mother from suffering. Even the timing of rituals, on the seventh day or after 49 days, follows beliefs about what happens to the dead.
However, other Buddhists would say the rituals are just as much, or more, for the living. Funerals constantly remind mourners of impermanence: Theravada monks chant that all conditioned things arise and pass away, and at Jodo Shinshu funerals Rennyo's letter on 'white ashes' reminds everyone that a radiant face in the morning may be ashes by evening. Funerals, sermons and memorial services bring the community together to support the bereaved. Some teachings suggest the living cannot change the dead person's kamma: the Dhammapada (165) says 'by oneself one is purified ... no one can purify another'. Jodo Shinshu Buddhists believe the dead are born in the Pure Land through Amida Buddha's vow, and Shinran said he never recited the nembutsu for his dead parents, so their funerals express gratitude rather than trying to help the dead. Also, Tibetan and Pure Land Buddhists hope for liberation or the Pure Land, not just a good rebirth.
In conclusion, I think the statement is true for many Theravada and Tibetan Buddhists, for whom merit-making and guiding the dead are central, but not for Jodo Shinshu Buddhists. Even where the dead are helped, the same rituals teach and comfort the living, and merit-making develops the generosity of those who give. So I disagree that helping the dead is the main purpose for Buddhists in general: the rituals have two purposes that work together.
Explanation
Top answers set Buddhist beliefs about helping the dead (merit, the bardo) against teachings that stress personal kamma, Amida's vow and the needs of the living, using named sources on both sides. Show diversity between Theravada, Tibetan and Japanese traditions, including Jodo Shinshu, and notice that a 'good rebirth' is not every tradition's aim. The conclusion should make a reasoned judgement, for example that the rituals serve two purposes.