'The Dhamma (Dharma) is the most important of the Three Jewels.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Buddhists would agree that the Dhamma is the most important of the Three Jewels. The Dhamma is the truth about the way things are, and the Buddha taught that it exists whether or not Buddhas appear in the world (Samyutta Nikaya 12.20). The Buddha therefore saw himself as a guide rather than a saviour: 'The Tathagatas (Buddhas) are only preachers' (Dhammapada 276). Before he died he told the monks that the Dhamma and Discipline would be their teacher, and that they should make the Dhamma their refuge rather than looking for a new leader. The Sangha also depends on the Dhamma, since its whole purpose is to preserve and practise it. On this view, it is the Dhamma, put into practice through the Eightfold Path, that actually brings a person to nibbana.
However, other Buddhists argue that the Buddha is at least as important. Without Siddhartha Gautama's Enlightenment, nobody in this age would know the Dhamma at all, and his life proves that a human being can become enlightened. In Mahayana Buddhism, Buddhas are active and present: Pure Land Buddhists rely on Amida Buddha's vow to bring them to the Pure Land, and devotion to Buddhas is central to their practice. Others stress the Sangha. For centuries the Dhamma survived only because monks memorised and recited it, and the Buddha told Ananda that spiritual friendship is 'the whole of the holy life'. In Tibetan Buddhism the lama is so important that students see their teacher as embodying all three refuges.
A further view is that the question itself is mistaken. Buddhists take refuge in the Three Jewels together, chanting all three refuges in the same breath, because each depends on the others: the Buddha discovered the Dhamma, the Dhamma is what the Sangha practises, and the Sangha makes the Buddha's example available today.
In conclusion, I think the Dhamma has the strongest claim to be most important, because it is the one jewel that the other two exist to serve: the Buddha's role was to teach it and the Sangha's role is to live it. However, the differences between traditions show that, in practice, Buddhists need all three, so the Dhamma is the most important only in the sense that it is the goal to which the Buddha and the Sangha point.
Explanation
High-level answers weigh the Dhamma against both the Buddha and the Sangha with developed reasons and use teachings such as Dhammapada 276 or the Mahaparinibbana Sutta to support each point. Including different traditions, such as Pure Land devotion to Amida or the Tibetan lama, strengthens the evaluation. Avoid a conclusion that simply repeats one side; explain why your chosen view is more convincing.