'The years Siddhartha spent as an ascetic were a waste of time.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Some people would agree that Siddhartha's years as an ascetic were a waste of time. For about six years he practised extreme self-denial with five companions, eating so little that, in his own account in the Mahasaccaka Sutta, his body became like a skeleton and he nearly died. None of this brought him Enlightenment. He became enlightened only after he gave up fasting, accepted a bowl of milk-rice from Sujata and meditated with a healthy body. In his first sermon, the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta, the Buddha himself called devotion to self-torment painful and unprofitable. Before that, he had mastered the meditation taught by Alara Kalama and Uddaka Ramaputta, but realised that it did not lead to nibbana. If extreme asceticism is the wrong path, the years he spent on it could be seen as years in which he could have been teaching.
However, most Buddhists would disagree. The ascetic years taught Siddhartha from experience that extreme self-denial does not work, just as the palace had taught him that luxury does not work. Because he had tried both extremes, he could teach the Middle Way with authority; it was a lesson learned, not a guess. The years also built the discipline, concentration and determination that he needed under the Bodhi tree to resist Mara and meditate through the night. His teachers' meditation states became part of Buddhist practice (samadhi), even though they were not the final goal. The five ascetics who left him became his first disciples at Sarnath, and Kondanna was the first to understand the Dhamma, so even their disappointment led to the beginning of the Sangha. Many Buddhists believe that nothing on the path is wasted, because each stage prepares for the next. Something of the ascetic spirit also survives in moderate forms, such as monks not eating after midday and lay Buddhists keeping extra precepts on uposatha days.
In conclusion, I disagree with the statement. Asceticism was not the way to Enlightenment, but the experience was a necessary step, because it showed Siddhartha, and all later Buddhists, why the Middle Way is right. Without those years the Buddha's teaching about avoiding extremes would carry less weight, so the time was not wasted but became one of his most important lessons.
Explanation
Top answers use the Buddha's own rejection of self-torment in the first sermon to support the statement, then argue that the experience was what made the Middle Way convincing. Including details such as the five ascetics becoming the first disciples gives the different view real weight. Avoid simply retelling the ascetic years; every paragraph should be weighing whether they were wasted.