'Rebirth in the Pure Land depends entirely on faith in Amitabha Buddha.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
[12 marks]
[+ 3 SPaG marks]
Model answer
Many Pure Land Buddhists, especially in the Jodo Shinshu tradition, would agree with this statement. Shinran taught that in this age of decline ordinary people are so full of passions that they cannot reach Enlightenment by their own efforts, which he called 'self power'. Instead, birth in the Pure Land comes entirely through the 'other power' of Amitabha's Primal Vow, in which he promised that all who sincerely entrust themselves to him will be born there. What matters is shinjin, true entrusting. Even the nembutsu, 'Namu Amida Butsu', is not a technique for earning rebirth but an expression of gratitude. The Tannisho, which records Shinran's sayings, teaches that if even a good person can be born in the Pure Land, how much more an evil person, showing that rebirth does not depend on moral achievement.
However, other Buddhists see it differently. Honen, Shinran's teacher, stressed the practice of reciting the nembutsu many times a day, and the Primal Vow itself speaks of calling Amitabha's name, so practice seems to matter as well as faith. The Contemplation Sutra teaches a series of visualisation meditations and emphasises moral conduct, and another of Amitabha's vows speaks of those who do good deeds and aspire to be born in his land. Many Chinese Pure Land Buddhists combine the nembutsu with meditation and the precepts, and Tibetan Buddhists practise phowa at the moment of death. There is also a subtle point in Shinran's own teaching: he believed that even faith is Amida's gift, not the believer's achievement, so strictly rebirth depends on Amitabha rather than on 'faith' as something a person produces. Zen Buddhists would add that the Pure Land is reached by purifying the mind, and Theravada Buddhists do not seek it at all.
In conclusion, I think the statement is true for Jodo Shinshu, but only if faith is understood as entrusting oneself to Amitabha's power rather than as a personal achievement. For other Pure Land traditions it goes too far, since practices such as reciting the nembutsu, meditation and ethical living also play a part. The statement is therefore accurate for one important tradition but not for Pure Land Buddhism as a whole.
Explanation
Top-level answers distinguish clearly between Honen's emphasis on the practice of the nembutsu and Shinran's teaching of 'other power' and shinjin, and use sources such as the Primal Vow, the Tannisho or the Contemplation Sutra. Recognising that for Shinran faith is itself Amida's gift is a sign of a sophisticated answer. Avoid treating all Pure Land Buddhists, or all Buddhists, as holding one view.