'Chanting is more useful as an aid to concentration than as an act of devotion.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Buddhists would agree that chanting is more useful as an aid to concentration. The Buddhist path leads to Enlightenment through meditation and wisdom, so chanting is valuable when it calms and steadies the mind. Chanting gives the mind one thing to rest on, slows the breath and settles the body, which is why puja in many viharas is followed by meditation and why Zen monks chant the Heart Sutra before zazen. The Dhammapada (35) praises 'a tamed mind', and verse 102 says that one word of the teaching which makes a person 'quiet' is worth more than a hundred meaningless verses. The Buddha is not a god who needs devotion, and verse 19 warns that someone who recites much of the teaching but does not live it has no share in the holy life, so chanting matters most when it helps practice.
However, many Buddhists see chanting mainly as devotion. When they chant the Three Refuges, they are expressing trust in the Buddha, the Dhamma and the Sangha, which the Dhammapada (190-192) calls 'the best refuge'. Pure Land Buddhists recite the nembutsu, 'Namu Amida Butsu', out of faith in Amida Buddha's vow, and Jodo Shinshu Buddhists say it in gratitude, not as a technique for concentration. Nichiren Buddhists chant 'Nam-myoho-renge-kyo' as devotion to the Lotus Sutra, and many Tibetan Buddhists recite Om mani padme hum to develop compassion and make merit for all beings. Devotion builds faith, humility and gratitude, which give people the motivation to keep practising.
In conclusion, I think the statement is true for some Buddhists, especially Theravada and Zen meditators, but not for Buddhism as a whole. For Pure Land Buddhists devotion is the heart of chanting. In practice the two support each other: devotion gives the motivation to practise, and a concentrated mind makes devotion deeper. So I disagree that one use is simply more useful; it depends on the tradition and on the person.
Explanation
Strong answers recognise that the specification describes chanting as both devotional and an aid to concentration, and weigh which matters more using teachings such as Dhammapada 35 and 190-192. Use different traditions, for example Zen and Theravada meditation against Pure Land and Nichiren devotion. Reach a conclusion that judges the statement, for example by arguing that the two uses support each other.