'Buddhists do not need to go to a temple to practise their religion.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Many Buddhists would agree that they do not need to go to a temple to practise. A simple shrine with a Buddha rupa, a candle and some flowers turns any room into a place of worship, and puja, chanting and meditation can be done at home every day. The Buddha gained Enlightenment sitting under a tree, not inside a temple, and he taught that each person must work out their own path: 'You yourself must make an effort' (Dhammapada 276). In the Mahaparinibbana Sutta he said that a follower who lives by the Dhamma honours him with the highest homage, which suggests that practice in daily life matters more than visiting a building. Many British Buddhists live a long way from a temple, so practising at home is the only realistic way for them.
However, other Buddhists argue that the temple is very important. The Sangha is one of the Three Refuges, and it is at a vihara or temple that the community of monks, nuns and lay people meets. In Theravada communities lay people make merit by offering food and robes (dana) to the monks, and the Itivuttaka describes householders and monks supporting each other, with the monks giving the Dhamma in return. Beginners may struggle to meditate without a teacher, and in Tibetan Buddhism learning from a lama in a gompa is seen as essential. Festivals such as Wesak, funerals and blessings also take place at temples, and some, with stupas containing relics, are places of pilgrimage. Without these, a Buddhist's practice might become isolated and weaker.
In conclusion, I agree that Buddhists do not strictly need a temple, because the heart of Buddhism is the training of one's own mind, which can happen anywhere. However, I think a temple is very valuable, because the Sangha provides teaching, encouragement and chances to make merit that are hard to find alone. A Buddhist could practise without a temple, but for most, regular contact with the Sangha makes their practice stronger, so the statement is true in principle but not the best way for most Buddhists to live.
Explanation
Top answers weigh the home against the temple using Buddhist teaching on both sides, such as Dhammapada 276 on personal effort and the Sangha as one of the Three Refuges. Show differences within Buddhism, for example the Theravada lay-monastic relationship or the Tibetan emphasis on the teacher. The conclusion should judge how far the statement is true, not just repeat both sides.