'Belief in rebirth is not necessary for Buddhists today.'
Evaluate this statement.
In your answer you should:
- refer to Buddhist teaching
- give reasoned arguments to support this statement
- give reasoned arguments to support a different point of view
- reach a justified conclusion.
Model answer
Some Buddhists today would agree that belief in rebirth is not necessary. Secular Buddhists, such as the British writer Stephen Batchelor, argue that the heart of the Buddha's teaching is practical: understanding suffering and craving and following the Eightfold Path to live wisely and kindly now. The benefits of meditation, metta and the precepts can be experienced in this life, and many people in Britain practise mindfulness and Buddhist ethics without believing in rebirth. In the Kalama Sutta the Buddha told people not to accept teachings simply because of tradition but to test them by experience, and rebirth cannot be tested in this way. The same sutta suggests that even if there is no next life, a person who lives without hatred lives happily here and now. Kamma can also be understood as shaping character in this life, and the six realms as states of mind, so the teachings still make sense without literal rebirth.
However, most Buddhists in both the Theravada and Mahayana traditions would disagree, because rebirth is woven into almost every part of the Buddha's teaching. On the night of his enlightenment the Buddha is said to have remembered his past lives, and the Jataka tales describe them. The goal of nibbana is release from samsara, the cycle of rebirth, so without rebirth the Third Noble Truth loses much of its meaning: if death ended everything, everyone would escape suffering at death whatever they had done. The law of kamma also seems unfair without rebirth, because many good people suffer and many harmful people prosper within a single lifetime. Practices such as merit-making for the dead, Tibetan rituals for the bardo, Pure Land Buddhists' hope of rebirth in Amitabha's Pure Land and the Mahayana Bodhisattva path, which lasts many lifetimes, all depend on rebirth. Belief in rebirth also encourages compassion for animals, which are part of the same cycle.
In conclusion, I think belief in rebirth is necessary for Buddhism as it has traditionally been taught, because the goal of ending samsara and the teaching on kamma depend on it. However, secular Buddhists show that some of the Buddha's teachings can benefit people without it, so a person can gain a great deal from Buddhist practice without this belief, even if their Buddhism is not complete in the traditional sense.
Explanation
Top answers explain why rebirth matters to traditional teachings such as samsara, nibbana and kamma, and fairly present the secular Buddhist view rather than dismissing it. Applying a teaching, such as the Kalama Sutta or the Third Noble Truth, directly to the statement lifts an answer into the higher levels. Make sure the conclusion follows from the arguments you have weighed.