Question 1
1 markGeiger and Marsden fired alpha particles at a thin gold foil. Their results, published in 1909, could not be explained by the model of the atom that most scientists accepted at that time.
Which model of the atom was this?
Choose your answer.
- A Bohr's model with electrons in fixed shells
- B Dalton's model of atoms as tiny solid spheres
- C Rutherford's model with a tiny central nucleus
- D Thomson's plum pudding model of the atom
Model answer
D (Thomson's plum pudding model of the atom)
Explanation
The order of the models is Dalton (solid spheres), Thomson (plum pudding, 1904), Rutherford (nuclear model, 1911) and Bohr (fixed electron shells, 1913). In 1909 the plum pudding model was the accepted model, and Geiger and Marsden's results did not fit it. A common slip is to choose Rutherford, but his nuclear model was the new model that explained the results.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / Thomson's plum pudding model of the atom
The only correct answer is D: Thomson suggested the plum pudding model in 1904 and it was the accepted model in 1909; Geiger and Marsden's results could not be explained by it, so Rutherford replaced it with the nuclear model in 1911. A is not correct because Bohr suggested his model in 1913, after these results; B is not correct because Dalton's solid-sphere model had already been replaced after the electron was discovered in 1897; C is not correct because Rutherford's nuclear model was suggested in 1911 to explain these results. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.