Question 1
1 markIn January 2025, the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) combined six sets of data from different scientific groups. Each group had estimated how much warmer the Earth was in 2024 than in 1850-1900.
All six groups found that 2024 was the warmest year on record, but their estimates were slightly different. The WMO gave the warming as 1.55 °C, with an uncertainty of ± 0.13 °C.
Which is the best explanation of why the six estimates were slightly different?
Choose your answer.
- A Only one of the six groups used real measurements that were made during 2024.
- B Some groups measured the temperatures in different units, such as °F instead of °C.
- C The Earth's temperature in 2024 kept changing while the groups were writing their reports.
- D The groups used different methods to combine measurements and fill the gaps between them.
Model answer
D - The groups used different methods to combine measurements and fill the gaps between them.
Explanation
Global temperature is worked out from thousands of measurements on land and at sea, but some regions have few measuring stations. Each group combines the measurements and fills the gaps in a slightly different way, so their estimates differ a little. That is why the WMO gives the warming with an uncertainty (1.55 ± 0.13 °C), even though every group agrees that 2024 was the warmest year on record.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / The groups used different methods to combine measurements and fill the gaps between them.
The only correct answer is D: the WMO says the estimates differ because of the groups' different methods; there are few measurements in some places, such as the polar regions and parts of the oceans, and each group combines the measurements and estimates the missing values in its own way. A is not correct because all six groups based their estimates on measurements made during 2024; B is not correct because temperatures in different units would be converted before they were compared, and a difference in units would give very large differences, not small ones; C is not correct because the temperature of 2024 was already measured, so it could not change while the reports were being written. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.