Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From Lawyers for Liberty: The NAACP and the Courts, 1930-1954 by Gerald Ashworth (fictional), published in 1988.
The NAACP's real power in these years lay in its national office in New York and, above all, in its team of lawyers. Led by Thurgood Marshall, the Legal Defense and Educational Fund chose its cases with great care, prepared them for years and argued them before the Supreme Court. Victories such as Smith v. Allwright in 1944, which ended the white primary, and the university cases of 1950 were won by a small group of highly trained specialists, not by mass action. Local branches raised money and found people willing to bring cases, but it was the national leadership that decided strategy and turned local grievances into constitutional arguments. Without this legal machine, the scattered efforts of Southern Black communities would have made little impression on the laws of the South.
Interpretation 2: From Branch by Branch: The NAACP in the Deep South, 1940-1955 by Patricia Lindqvist (fictional), published in 2009.
Historians have often told the NAACP's story from its New York office, but its strength in the South lay in hundreds of local branches. These were run by teachers, ministers, small business owners and railway workers who gave up their evenings to the cause, often at great personal risk. They collected evidence of police brutality, helped neighbours to pay the poll tax and register to vote, and found the parents and students who were brave enough to put their names to lawsuits. In Florida, Harry T. Moore built up the state's branches and helped thousands of Black citizens to register before he was killed by a bomb in 1951. The lawyers in New York could win cases only because local people had already done the dangerous work of organising.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about the main strength of the NAACP in the early 1950s. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is about where the NAACP's strength lay. Interpretation 1 argues that its 'real power' was in the national office and 'above all, in its team of lawyers' led by Thurgood Marshall, and that its victories were 'won by a small group of highly trained specialists, not by mass action'. It gives local branches only a supporting role: they 'raised money and found people willing to bring cases'. Interpretation 2 argues the opposite, that its strength 'lay in hundreds of local branches' run by teachers, ministers and workers who registered voters and found people to bring lawsuits, such as Harry T. Moore in Florida. It claims the lawyers 'could win cases only because local people had already done the dangerous work'. So Interpretation 1 sees the NAACP's strength coming from the top, while Interpretation 2 sees it coming from ordinary members at the bottom.
Explanation
Top answers state the overall difference, national lawyers against local branches, and support it with a detail from each interpretation. Answers that list what each interpretation mentions without saying how the views differ stay in Level 1. There is no need to explain why the historians disagree in this question.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is about where the NAACP's strength came from: Interpretation 1 sees it in the national leadership and its lawyers (from the top), while Interpretation 2 sees it in the local branches and ordinary members in the South (from the bottom). Interpretation 1: 'real power ... lay in its national office in New York and, above all, in its team of lawyers'; Thurgood Marshall and the Legal Defense and Educational Fund; victories 'won by a small group of highly trained specialists, not by mass action'; local branches only 'raised money and found people willing to bring cases'; 'it was the national leadership that decided strategy'. Interpretation 2: 'its strength in the South lay in hundreds of local branches' run by 'teachers, ministers, small business owners and railway workers'; they registered voters, collected evidence and found plaintiffs; Harry T. Moore in Florida; 'The lawyers in New York could win cases only because local people had already done the dangerous work'. Level 2 needs this difference of view supported from both interpretations. Answers that give only surface differences (e.g. 'Interpretation 1 mentions Smith v. Allwright and Interpretation 2 mentions Florida') or summarise each interpretation in turn without stating the difference stay in Level 1. Do not credit the claim that Interpretation 2 says the lawyers were unimportant (it says they depended on local work), or that Interpretation 1 ignores local branches (it gives them a minor role). Do not credit explanations of why the historians disagree (that is a different question).